Grocery Stores near West Islip, NY

30 locations found near West Islip
View Map

“I ordered stuffed artichokes from deli counter they are very good and very nice service I would recommend getting them here over other local stores...happy holidays...”

3.8 Good56 Reviews

“Stop and Shop pricing is very reasonable, has a great loyalty rewards program and is always clean. The staff are always friendly and this is why I only shop here for groceries.”

3.5 Good41 Reviews

“I only have positive things to say as well. My family used to visit the shop in Ridgewood and we finally made it to the Huntington Location. Our favorite as the krainerwurst, cervelat, chicken rolls, pretzel rolls (ask for the salt, they will give you a container). There is also a bunch of German / European items throughout the store, such as mustards, sauces, and candies. They have adorable Christmas shaped fondant candies that would be too cute for me to even want to eat - they were a little expensive or I would have bought them all. Oh and they have other candies shaped like a pig which I wanted as well. Customer service is top notch. Needless to say, I will be back.”

4.8 Superb142 Reviews

“My husband and I love the Farmingdale store not just bc of their products but their amazing staff. The assistance I’ve received is beyond other stores and is greatly appreciated!!”

4.7 Superb184 Reviews

“The most helpful employees of any supermarket I have ever been in! And anytime they have an item on sale, they always have it in the store. So lucky to have this Shop Rite close to home”

4.5 Superb305 Reviews

“Fairly priced produce (well except for the berries) good selection of meats, prepared foods, and Italian products. Its my replacement for Best Market since they were replaced by Lidl, though the prices are not quite as good. It definitely has a loyal clientele, worth checking out.”

4.4 Superb222 Reviews

“The best around. Sherry’s Market is one of a kind. Healthiest products and supplements you won’t find anywhere else. Endless organic and vegan options that will not disappoint. Nutritionist is very knowledgeable and helpful friendly staff.”

4.6 Superb80 Reviews

“Always a large selection of food everyday something different daughter's been taking over by different people from the original owner and it's being improved keep up the good work guys”

4.6 Superb80 Reviews

“Authentic Italian Pork Store/Butcher.They are old-school in the best way possible.They have the skill and knowledge to breakdown the whole animal…- Perfectly cut steaks and roasts.- Absolutely amazing sausages.- Expertly crafted cured meat.- Amazing meat bread.Their mozzarella is excellent too.Finally, they’ll actually make you a custom sausage. Who else does that?”

4.8 Superb48 Reviews

“The Grilled chicken they make here is amazing! I ordered the medium size combo and came with rice and salad which were also fantastic. All for the price of $9.50. Great service, great people. Plenty of parking.”

4.4 Superb128 Reviews

“Good for fruits and vegetables that you can't find in most supermarkets - the mainstream fruits and vegetables are a bit more expensive.The meats are very reasonable!”

4.4 Superb115 Reviews

“I drove all the way 1 h, and this store is not like the one in Astoria we used to go . Didn't have a lot of things . I can't wait to open in Astoria again .”

4.6 Superb56 Reviews

“Simply the most authentic delicious food in Suffolk county, perhaps on all of Long Island! Like being in my abuela’s and mom’s kitchen. Great friendly staff too. Felix Navidad!???️✌️”

4.7 Superb43 Reviews

“Pretty crowded always, but thats to be expected. Excellent customer service. Specifically shout out to the cashier Krystal who just asked so simply yet so genuine about my day.”

4.5 Superb64 Reviews

“Enjoy eating lunch, and sometimes dinner at their buffet. Has a small seating area. Found the food freshly made, and healthy eating. The grocery store has a large selection of items for purchase. Has a south-of-the-border feeling while inside. I am still teaching myself Spanish, the staff is very cooperative with my unique sign language, and the toddler like pointing to what I wish to purchase. Happy with the choice offered of self-check-out for a fast shopping experience.”

4.4 Superb87 Reviews

“Was very impressed with all the different varieties they had in the store . Everything was well stocked and the store was extremely clean . The gentleman at the counter was very polite and helpful . Ordered Halal meat ? which was very clean and well cut . Thank you and you will be seeing me again .”

4.8 Superb31 Reviews

“I’ve been seeing these new specials all over social media and decided to give Key Food a shot. Super clean store, great pricing (especially on the online specials they feature) and friendly staff. Will be my new go to store in Massapequa.”

4.3 Superb116 Reviews

“Always a good shopping experience even on christmas eve.When I got there around 2:15. It was a little busy after 40 minutes of shopping. There was no lines and three of the staff members helped me tremendously.I always recommend this food store and if you want meat and produce, they simply are the best.Definitely recommended.”

4.3 Superb109 Reviews

“Had a few heroes last week. 2 chicken cutlet and 2 Italian. The 5 star is for the heroes. Absolutely great. Top notch. Only item which could use some improvement are the salads. We've all had macaroni, coleslaw and potato salad and most times we all say it's ok. They were ok but I wish they were homemade. Nothing better than homemade. Again, the heroes are GREAT.”

4.6 Superb39 Reviews

“If you're looking for Hispanic Culture ingredients, baked goods, or snacks among so much more this is an excellent choice for all sorts of items you won't see in a typical supermarket depending on your area. Of course they carry many standard supermarket items.”

4.5 Superb45 Reviews

“Looking for Dominican food? This spot has a vast majority of food. Although it's a hole in the wall within a supermarket their food and service is great! Those hole in the walls can be hit or miss this is definitely a HIT!!!”

4.3 Superb84 Reviews

“Nice place , very clean and organized. Prices are good, small store but well stocked with a variety of choices. The guy behind the register was very courteous. Overall a good place stop for Indian grocery before Hicksville. Oh and most important indian beers are there too!”

5 Superb19 Reviews

“I love Dairy Barn, now GBG. The owner might want to think about keeping chocolate donuts in fridge when it is hot out and doors are kept open. The chocolate melted :-)”

4.9 Superb20 Reviews

“I can’t understand why anyone would say this store is overpriced, maybe they want it free everything in this shop is cheaper than all supermarket nearby and far. We use to drive to Queens to buy our Jamaican stuff and it is more expensive there , so we started shopping at this store instead.It’s not a big place but you can get a lot of Caribbean items there . The owner is a very nice person and his family..”

4.6 Superb31 Reviews

“Great service and great food . Speaks English and Spanish. They also accept apple pay. They have many options of food and they cater too. I love buying rice from them. 10/10 Another plus they always have ready avocados.”

4.4 Superb47 Reviews

“Very impressed! I said that 3 times inside the store, so that is saying much. First time in a Lidl and very happy with their fruit, bakery and overall prices. They also carry brand names so there are a lot of choices. Crazy how we got a whole Butterball Turkey for $13 total! I liked Lidl better than Aldi and we'll be back :)”

4.3 Superb66 Reviews

“Been going here everyday for years. Everyone is so super friendly. Great prices and amazing food. Always fresh also. Facility is very clean inside and they take meticulous care of their kitchen as well. No way you can’t be satisfied coming here.”

4.5 Superb36 Reviews

“This place is the real deal. Go ahead and walk through the door (it’s unmarked so look for the ??). I came in search of divella pasta that’s hard to find in the grocery stores and left with so much more! Excellent selection of quality products, delicious pasta, breads, and sweets made on site, and amazing freshly made pizzas. Reasonably priced and worth every penny for the authentic, very happy experience.”

4.9 Superb17 Reviews

“Greek grocer that has everything you greek you need or want at great prices.Parking: There are only two spots in front of the store, otherwise it's street parking.”

4.9 Superb15 Reviews

You May Also Like