Citadel Coins is a highly professional and welcoming coin store known for its great selection and fair prices. Despite the busy environment, customers find the staff to be friendly, knowledgeable, and easy to work with. Many reviews highlight the fair and reasonable offers received when selling coins, often exceeding expectations. Customers appreciate the honesty and expertise of the staff, especially Martin and Gerard, who are described as sharp, fair, and helpful. The store is praised for its wide variety of coins and collections, with some mentioning that they will return for future transactions. Appointments are recommended, but staff are flexible and accommodating if customers run late. The owner is noted for providing valuable advice and taking the time to assist with future purchases and want lists. Citadel Coins is also recognized for its high-quality coin holders, which enhance the presentation of coins with their excellent writing. Overall, the store offers a positive experience, combining professionalism, fair pricing, and good customer service, making it a highly recommended place for buying or selling coins.
Even amongst the chaos of a busy shop pushing appointments behind, Citadel Coins was a great experience and extremely professional all the way through.
September 2025
I have met with Martin from Citadel coins a couple of times. In both instances he was very fair and reasonable. The information he provided about my items was very interesting. Without a doubt, Citadel coins will always be my first choice. To anyone wanting to sell their coin and/or other collections that they buy... read full comment
August 2025
Amazing coin store; the owners are super nice. Ticket Prices are very fair, and a huge variety. Just remember to make an appointment before coming. Highly recommended.
