Thrift Stores near Carlisle, OH

12 locations found near Carlisle

“Probably one of the nicest Goodwill stores I've ever shopped at. The place was very well organized and had exceptional prices on most everything. Although I didn't find anything this time, I'm glad I noticed the store on my Ohio road trip.”

2.6 Average16 Reviews

“I think I want to come back every October because all of the booths had such cute Halloween decorations. It's very large with almost all of the booths filled, so give yourself time to look around. I think it took us 3 hours to go through most of the booths thoroughly.”

4.3 Superb142 Reviews

“Kool place, buddy got a ratrod from here, it had been sitting forever and I got the liberty of rubbing her down and knocking off the dust and cobwebs, before helping do some updates, we fabbed up some metal webs to go in the back windows that were made of thin rebar and magnetically attached to remove them, other updates such and engine, wheels and wide white walls were installed as well as some gauges and other shiny dress up things.. the doors originally had some hand painted logos, that were removed and changed for the new owner to say "Dirty 30" it's a Ford and yes 1930 and the condition it was in was dirty, but now it's "Dirtyness" is visual beauty in the old school car game.. Rick and Kimberly Shirk are the current owners.. I'll add photos and video soon.. ..”

4.5 Superb66 Reviews

“Love this store. The staff are always friendly and helpful. It's clean, organized, and relatively large. Easy to drive in and out of, always had parking available. They have a wide variety of things. They just raised their prices and are getting on the expensive side. They do, however, have 50% off a different colored tag every day, so that helps .”

4.3 Superb68 Reviews

“Great thrift store with a lot of good finds. They have daily specials where the color tag corresponds to a special price. For the day I went, the blue and red tags were 50% off.”

3.9 Good109 Reviews

“Smaller place unfortunately, but whoever is working here has picked better clothes quality than other goodwill stores. Some really good feminine dresses and skirts and such were found.”

3.5 Good100 Reviews

“Not a bad store or bad location I'll have to give this store another chance when I'm in Middletown again. Staff was nice and I had to buy that bunny for my friend just because of the lashes”

3.4 Good59 Reviews

“Nice store found some good finds and the staff I always interacted with are kind. It's definitely a hit or miss like all thrift stores but doesn't stop me from enjoying browsing. Always check back you never know what you'll find”

3.4 Good96 Reviews

“Not a bad place. Definitely has been picked over though but I found some great finds and the cashier/supervisor Olivia I think her name was is really friendly. Store was clean and put together”

3.1 Average61 Reviews

“This store has a great selection of all types of items. Everyone was very polite. The manager was training a new cashier, they were so friendly and inviting when I walked in. Hands down best pricing compared to other stores!!! The store is clean and orginized. Things have a place not just stacked to the brim with garbage. Will be returning found my new go to place.”

3.1 Average91 Reviews

“WHAT GOT ME FROM THE MOMENT I WALKED IN THE DOOR IS THEY HAVE EVERYTHING THAT YOU NEED CLOTHES THAT IS AND VERY REASONABLE ON THEIR PRICES. THEY ARE CHEAPER THEN THE GOODWILL AND SALVATION ARMY. AND WELL ORGANIZED. THEY HAD A LOT OF THERE SNEAKERS ON CLEARANCE 90% OFF IM TALKING GOOD BRAND NAMES. THEY HAVE LEVI'S NIKE AND ALSO LEATHER JACKETS.”

3.2 Average126 Reviews

“Was greeted very nicely, lots of things to browse through, with an amazing selection. Found some amazing finds!! Will definitely be returning as often as possible:)”

2.1 Poor63 Reviews