“Caught this place 1/2 hour before closing time but was not rushed out by staff! I could of and would have spent more time if it was available to look around. Inventory was plentiful for darts id say they had it all. Would love to revisit without kids and have more time to try out some darts! Great shop from first impressions! Bought some flights and shafts but lots of steel tip darts to choose from. Pricing seemed to be fair from my experience!”
“I’m so excited that I got to come to the Colonial Coin and Jewelry store! We even got to meet Gary and Justin! Thank you for the beginning of my nickel collection!!! ?❤️✨”
“Hidden gem in downtown Cleveland. Owner is one of a kind…family first man! The dog is super cool too. Enjoy this mellow zen like atmosphere. Quality products for a great price. You get what ya pay for here. Stop buying your guy boring gifts and come here first! Love this place!”
“Very organized, quick and easy to find desired items and there prices are awesome! The owner is extremely nice to, this should be anyone's first option for a hobbie store”
“I came in they greeted me instantly, then proceeded to helped me find * Exactly what I was Looking for.... Phonominal Service and Awesome Staff. I won't go ANYWHERE ELSE for My Sports Cards, NEVER. !!!!! Thank You. You Guys ROCK. !!!! ✌️Addy~•°”
“Knowledgable, friendly, informative, and HONEST. I only spoke over the phone with the owner, but I got more help from him than I did with any other coin dealer in the area. I will 100% be doing business in the future.”
“Micheal's you need to give the cashier Lindsy a raise. I have never in my life went to a store and had a worker go above and beyond to help me find my item. She didn't tell me to go to this isle or point in the direction the item was she took me there. Even though she walked with a limp, she was more than happy to help me. Sheasked what I was making and I felt as she valued me as a customer.”
“I always have a fear they will close. I love this place. Jewelry supplies, painting supplies, even interesting products/entertainment for kids! But a little disappointed they stopped carrying a particular brand of cotton t shirts, it was super soft, not thick and itchy. It probably didn't hold up well during the crafting process.”
“A wonderful FLGS: open and well-lit, well-stocked without being cluttered. I had a great conversation with the owner today when I stopped in with my wife for the first time - we've just moved to the area and I wanted to check out our gaming options; Critical Hit checked every box for us. We didn't make any purchases today but will absolutely be back. The owner is extremely knowledgeable about both the products in the store and the culture and history surrounding them - from Pokémon Cards to indie TTRPGs, Critical Hit doesn't miss. P.S. The shop dog, Rufus, is a chatty little sweetheart - and the owner is very experienced at talking customers through meeting him! I was honored to meet the shop's brave protector up close.”