Bexley Liquor Agency is a small neighborhood liquor store located on E Livingston Avenue, next to a Subway. Despite its unassuming appearance, the store offers a diverse selection of alcoholic beverages, including allocated bourbons that are highly sought after. The store is cash-only, and the parking lot can be quite busy and difficult to navigate, especially during peak hours. However, the staff is described as friendly and helpful, assisting customers efficiently. While the store's location may attract some undesirable activities, the majority of customers are reported to be cool and just want to get in and out with their purchases. The store is praised for its extensive selection, allowing customers to find unique and hard-to-find items. Overall, Bexley Liquor Agency is a reliable liquor store with a good selection, friendly staff, and a lively atmosphere, making it a go-to spot for many in the local community.