Carfagna's is a quaint Italian market known for its quality selection of goods, including sauces, fresh and dry pasta, baked desserts, antipasti, and salads. The butcher and seafood counters offer excellent products, and the staff is knowledgeable and friendly. The market also features a section with freshly cooked Italian take-home items, and their pizza, particularly the thin-crust pepperoni, is delicious. In addition to the market, Carfagna's has a fantastic restaurant next door and a great cooking school. Customers praise the market's amazing variety of Italian imports, well-maintained products, and excellent customer service. The dining experience at the restaurant is also highly regarded, with top-notch food, wine, and service. Overall, Carfagna's is a Columbus institution for lovers of Italian cuisine.