Donatos Pizza Home Office receives mixed reviews that highlight significant inconsistencies in both product quality and customer service across different locations. Several reviews from Colorado and Ohio note that franchise locations, particularly in Red Robin restaurants, are not following the correct recipes, leading to poorly made pizzas with incorrect amounts of sauce and pepperoni. This is damaging to the brand's reputation for customers familiar with the authentic Ohio product. Customer service experiences are frequently described as terrible, horrible, and disappointing. Reports include rude and unpleasant staff, with employees appearing angry and lacking basic customer service skills. One account details an unhelpful area manager who became loud, obnoxious, and defensive when concerns were raised. Other incidents mention employees laughing at customers, ignoring phone calls, and providing service with a stank demeanor. Multiple reviewers observe that the staff seem like they do not want to be there, noting a visible decline over many years with constantly changing management. However, the core product itself receives positive remarks when made correctly, with the pizza and subs described as actually pretty good, very good, and of the remembered quality and flavor that excites loyal customers. The business also functions efficiently as a logistical hub for receiving, with clear instructions for drivers for easy backing and unloading. Ultimately, while the authentic pizza is cherished, inconsistent execution and persistently poor customer service at various locations present a serious challenge for the business.
Donatos Bexley, Ohio 43227 delivered this sub tonight . ASHMED!! LOOKS LIKE A BURNT COOKIE!! SO, SO DISSAPOINTED IN THIS TERRIBLE RESTRAUNT.
January 2026
I don't have a problem with your food. I have a problem with the new very veggie commercial. Watching a grown man eat a slice of pizza at the same time talking. Haven't you heard of manners. Our children now days don't learn the things we did at least show them basic manners.
November 2025
I use my points to order pizza on November 17, 2025 to where all I was responsible for with the delivery charge on November 18, 2025 Donatos Pizza came back and charged me 25 additional dollars Now, if you’re not thieves what are you That’s stealing