Sheetz of New Albany offers a convenient and versatile experience for customers. The store provides award-winning Made-To-Order food and handcrafted Sheetz Bros. Coffeez drinks, along with a variety of packaged snacks, drinks, tobacco, and CBD products. Customers praise the quality of the food, particularly the chicken bacon ranch flatbread, and appreciate the honesty and helpfulness of the staff, who once returned a lost wallet. While the gas prices are considered reasonable, some customers have noted a decline in the quality of the food as the chain has expanded. Overall, Sheetz is a popular destination for those seeking a quick and satisfying meal or snack, with a focus on convenience and variety.
I visited this location today around 11am and I couldn't of been more pleased with the service. The gentleman working the counter was very nice and helpful. The gentleman that made my pumpkin latte was also very nice and helpful. The food and drink was perfect! Keep up the good work!
September 2025
Awarding five stars because the cook turned my casual snack run into a VIP hot dog tasting experience with a free roller dog!!!
May 2025
Depends on what time you go. I had to cancel my food order and get a refund because I was waiting almost 30 mins and it still wasn't even started and all it was was jalapeño poppers. They get very busy close to and right after bar closing time. So dont going during that time.
