The Island House Hotel is a charming, older hotel known for its historical character and great location. Guests appreciate the attentive staff, who provide excellent service and hospitality. The hotel is conveniently situated within walking distance of shops, restaurants, and a beautiful beach, making it an ideal getaway. Rooms are described as quaint and comfortable, with some visitors noting the cozy atmosphere and spaciousness for families. However, some reviews mention areas needing improvement, such as the lobby, which could benefit from freshening up, and the presence of a musty smell in certain areas. Guests have also noted that the water temperature in the showers can be lukewarm at times. Despite these drawbacks, the hotel offers a nostalgic experience for those who enjoy history. While the pub was closed and no continental breakfast was available, the overall experience at The Island House Hotel is positive, with many guests expressing a desire to return and recommend it to others.
Just had my first visit to the Island House. What a great old style hotel. Lisa and staff are first rate. Great location as well. Looking forward to our next stay. Keep up the good work!
October 2023
Nice, old world charm, with an awesome staff. Located near the Put-in-bay Ferry, shops and entertainment.
August 2023
Nice older hotel with a great deal of potential. Staff was super attentive. Lobby could use some freshening up. There was a musty smell throughout. Room was on the small side but comfortable. Because it could use some renovations, I do think it was on the pricey side.
