Casey's is a clean and friendly business that offers good pizza and a variety of convenience items. The inside is nice, and the staff are friendly and helpful, providing awesome service. Customers enjoy the pizza, which is described as pretty good and consistently tasty, with some reviews highlighting it as "amazing." The store also has a good selection of drinks, including slushies that have a McDonald's ice cream level consistency, although they sometimes don't work. Many appreciate the store's clean bathrooms and clear aisles. The staff, especially one named Tara, are praised for their caring attitude and multitasking skills, making customers feel welcomed. The store's selection of grinds, caramel, and orange citrus drinks is appreciated, and some customers suggest adding new flavors like cinnamon roll. Overall, Casey's is highly recommended for its clean environment, friendly staff, and tasty pizza, with some customers hoping for more locations in other states.
Very nice, friendly and welcoming employees, better than most convenience/gas stations around Upper Sandusky, Ohio.Caseys rewards are awesome too. They can add up fast and be redeemed for gas or Casey's cash to use in the store. 💯
October 2025
Staff in here is great!! Always friendly, and always have my order (smokes) ready when I get to the counter! Now thats customer service!!!! Great job ladies!!! And a huge thank you!
October 2025
Gas station with large convenience store that has an expanded food menu, apart from that it does all the gas station convenience store things.
