“I needed to do some touch up and had a very difficult time matching the paint our contractor used. After three attempts and many $$$ later, Ethan helped us find a solution. It wasn't easy and took him quite some time but he SAVED us so much time and additional $. We had screwed things up so much that if we didn't find a correct paint match we would have had to repaint 1500sqft that icludes a two story great room. I appreciate Ethan and his willingness to stick to it until we found a fix. Thank you!”
7:30AM - 5PM
781 Reynoldsburg - New Albany Rd, Blacklick
Paint Stores
“Excellently polite and knowledgeable staff willing to lend a hand or expertise when needed. We bought a fixer upper house in Blacklick and for some time I think I was at Creative Paints at least twice a week. They always took great care of us and I would highly recommend their store”
“I want to leave you a five star review for being apart of the independent locally owned paint businesses across America. I couldn’t find a Facebook page to give you a tag and I know these are worth their weight in gold!! Congratulations on building America on Small BusinessesLove, Blue Mist Paint and Flooring, SC”
7:30AM - 5PM
4738 N High St, Columbus
Paint Stores
“Excellent customer service! This shop reminds me of how paint and hardware stores felt when I was a kid — friendly, helpful, and genuinely interested in your project. The staff offered great suggestions and really took the time to help me find what would work best. I can’t remember the last time someone actually asked what I was painting, and it honestly took me by surprise in the best way.
They color-matched our trim perfectly to our funky wallpaper, and their cabinet paint recommendation left such a smooth, enamel-like finish that now I’m tempted to repaint all the trim in the house. It’s rare to find this kind of personal service anymore. Highly recommend!”
“Looking for top quality deck paint and they had it in stock! The guys in there are knowledgable and had some good tips for application. Fast service and they even gave me the sale price I wasn't aware of. Plus Spongebob was on the tv while I waited. Well done, guys!”
“Mr. Joesph has been helpful to me on multiple occasions. His employees are awesome and that is a clear example of his leadership. If you have the option of this store vs another, choose this one for great and friendly service!”
“Friendly service and knowledgeable staff. I was able to get the deck stain at a reasonable price. I have used PPG paint for years. Great quality and long lasting. Highly recommend this store and it's product.”
“I LOVE this sherwin location. I usually work with Jonathon. He always has wonderful customer service skills and is very knowledgeable about their products as well as other paint products that are not strictly sherwin. I had the opportunity to go to a different store that was more convenient and closer, but I decided to go to this store and I’m glad I did! Great service, product and staff!”
“In the past 4 years I have really gotten into being my own home handyman. During this early transformation I tried several paint stores and settled on Sherwin-Williams on Sawmill near Home Road, mostly because of the manager, Dan H. He is universally pleasant and has given me excellent service and advice.”
“We needed to paint our living & dining rooms, and the sales associate Ten at the 5th Ave location was super helpful with the color choice, sheen, amount and accessories. Great service - made all the difference. Highly recommend!!!”
“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5/5 – Joy is a true gem!
If you’re heading to the Gahanna location, do yourself a favor and ask for Joy — she is truly out of this world! We had the absolute pleasure of working with her, and she went above and beyond to make our experience incredible.
Joy took an entire hour out of her day to help us match colors, offer thoughtful suggestions, and make sure we felt confident in every choice. Her attention to detail, patience, and genuine passion for what she does made all the difference.
She’s not just helpful — she’s exceptional. If you need anything, Joy is your girl. The name fits her perfectly because working with her was an absolute joy!”
“I want to give a shout out to Kyle, who helped me today at Sherwin-Williams. He is a young man, but really seem to have it all together with customer service and multitasking. I will definitely visit the Sherwin Wiliams again.”
“Tim was fantastic and helpful! This store mostly services commerical painters, but Tim provided wonderful assistance to my husband and I with color matching. He was patient, knowledgeable, and took time to thoroughly match the colors we brought in. He even stayed past the store's closing time to help us! It is rare to find service like this - we greatly appreciated his work ethic and pleasant disposition!”
“Lekan and Alex are absolutely fantastic and provide fantastic service. Great selection of paints and primers and they always make my paint orders with speed and accuracy. Saves my company time and money consistently which I can pass savings onto my customers.”
“I am a painter for a commercial company and I am in this store multiple time a week Preston the store manager has great customer service skills and very knowledgeable on all the products sherwin williams offers. By far my favorite location to go to. Anyone who needs painting products or has questions ask for Preston!!”
6AM - 5PM
4864 Evanswood Dr, Columbus
Paint Stores
“I deal with Matt at this store on a semi-regular basis and he's always very friendly, helpful, knowledgeable, and regularly goes above and beyond what I ask of him.”
“Lucas is very knowledgeable and was very helpful answering all my questions and processing my order quickly. They had so many colors to choose from. I will visit this store again for my future painting needs.”