Casey’s in Broken Arrow, OK, is known for its delicious pizza, made with scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings. The location offers pizza delivery and pickup, along with a selection of appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and household essentials. Many customers enjoy the pizza but recommend double-checking orders to ensure accuracy. The service is highlighted as friendly and helpful, with one employee receiving special praise for exceptional customer service. While the pizza is generally well-received, there have been occasional delays in orders. Some customers have noted issues with gas pump payment systems and communication regarding fuel availability. However, the store has a new manager and team members working to improve operations. The parking is ample, and the environment is kid-friendly, making it a convenient stop for families. Overall, Casey’s aims to provide quality food and service, making it a popular choice for both dining in and taking out.
Please quit smashing the caramel out of the caramello. I enjoy them inside the chocolate—not on the wrapper & forced to eat a shell of chocolate of a caramello. Thank you
February 2024
Taylor is awesome!! Great customer service, very kind and helpful. 10/10 will be buying more pizza from Casey’s on 51 highway!!
Parking: Plenty of parking!
Kid-friendliness: Super easy and understanding of littles!
December 2023
Dang good pizza order carry out ask for double cheese ?
