Casey's in El Reno is a popular gas station known for its friendly staff and clean facilities. The pizza is widely praised as being "so flippin' good," though some customers have experienced issues with customization orders. While the kitchen staff can sometimes seem overwhelmed, especially during busy hours, the front-of-house employees are consistently described as helpful and pleasant. The bathrooms, in particular, are well-maintained, with a customer service representative named Tyler keeping the men's restroom "immaculate" at night. Despite a few isolated incidents of long wait times or order mix-ups, the overall consensus is that Casey's is a great gas station with a good food selection, including no-ethanol fuel options. While the business may be short-staffed at times, the general experience is positive, with customers praising the clean store and friendly atmosphere.
They are the only location with the wide range of a different fuels until you get to Amarillo heading west. It is unfortunate if you are in need of socialized fuel such as E 85.
May 2026
This location is convenient because I drive by twice a day. I like their Casey’s branded product but the gas pumps are JUNK especially for a company this size. Pumps may work or may not it is very hit and miss and don’t ever expect to get a receipt at the pump.
May 2026
Typical gas station with hot dogs , pizza and other packaged junk food without tables or service. This is not a restaurant.
