Casey's is a convenient stop with a great rewards program for gas, but reviews for their pizza are mixed. Some customers find the pizza cold and greasy, recommending Godfather's Pizza from Love's instead. Despite this, others have had fantastic experiences with Casey's pizza and prefer it over other options.
Complete disappointment This is NOT a Casey this is Sketch
April 2024
Let me preface this by saying I'm a QuikTrip girl through and through. ? But this Casey's is on my way to various places I frequent, and the experience has been fantastic every time, and I will admit that their pizza is better.
September 2023
Rewards program is great and usually try to fill up at a Casey's. That said, can't say the same for the food. Pizza is usually cold in the self serve cabinet. Also the pizza us usually dripping in grease and is unedible. Will buy gas at Casey's but will go to Love's and get a good Godfather's pizza.
