Plato's Closet Markham is a popular thrift store where customers can buy, sell, and trade men’s and women’s casual clothing and accessories. Open seven days a week, it offers a wide selection of trendy, gently-used items from brands like Nike, Adidas, Aritzia, Oak+Fort, Frank and Oak, Club Monaco, Converse, Vans, H&M, and American Eagle, often at discounted prices. The store welcomes customers to bring in clothing for cash or trade without needing an appointment, accepting all seasons and year-round.
Many reviewers appreciate the easy-to-browse layout and the filtered selection of clothes, making second-hand shopping straightforward. The staff is generally described as polite, friendly, and helpful, with some reviewers noting exceptional service from staff members who go out of their way to assist, such as helping customers try on clothes or providing quick checkout. Customers have found high-quality, almost new items in excellent condition, including name brands like Nike, North Face, OVO, and NBA merchandise, often priced between $8 and $40.
Some reviews mention that the selection can vary, and occasionally the store may not accept certain clothes, which can be frustrating. However, overall, many customers find the store to be a good place to find stylish clothing at affordable prices. The staff's helpfulness and the quality of items make Plato’s Closet Markham a favored spot for those looking for trendy second-hand fashion.
Selling process was easy; I took some items back that I thought I could get more somewhere else. Sales Associates were super nice and friendly. It’s a bit disorganized to shop in there but my boyfriend found a few things so we left happy.
October 2026
I'm sure if I'd have looked there would have been cool clothes. I was there for bags and what they had was just ok. I visited 2 locations in the area, this one was the smaller one.
August 2026
Anna was very sweet! Found some great clothing options for cheap for an upcoming concert.
