Gun Shops near Dillsburg, PA

“Made an internet purchase order. Had it shipped to store. came in within a week. amazing customer service. Travis & Frank were amazing to deal with. Definitely on the top of my local Gun Shops.”

“I do not reviews often, but this is deserving of it! This store is awesome. I’ll give you a shortened version of what compelled me to type this review. I attempted to purchase a gun online from Buffalo Gap Outfitters and they hung with me for 2 days during an issue with my credit card company! They held onto the gun and let me get it figured out. A lot of places would have just told me to hit the road, but not these guys. This store is for the working man who has bad luck! And most of us that shop in gun stores are working men with bad luck! Thanks for the customer service! I’d recommend you to anybody!”

“Excellent selection and wonderful staff. I always enjoy a trip to Dover Tactical and walk away a satisfied customer, knowing I received a fair deal, and a nice addition to my collection. Always a pleasure to see Kali too!

Update to original review. Just purchased my 4th addition to my collection from Dover Tactical. Always a fair deal, exceptional and knowledgeable staff, and loving from Kali while you wait for your paperwork to be processed. Still a fan and will always come back to support the crew at Dover Tactical. Thanks guys! I love my Judge.”

“If you are looking for service with a personal touch, knowledgeable staff, fair prices and service you can count on after the sale, The Hunters Trading Post is your kind of sporting goods shop. They have a great selection of used and new firearms, ammunition, and hunting accessories. Best of all the are just great people. I love this place and bet you will too.

Miles”

“Awsome service. Needed a small part for on Tenpoint Stealth , they shipped that day and I had 2 days later. Faster than my dealer could get it for me. Great service and derfinately wll use them for my archery needs. Thanks BSS.”

“Great selection of ammo that is more for genuine protection and hunting rather than just FMJ rounds. Their parts wall maybe be a few feet long but they ensure it's packed full of great quality items. Pricing for parts are fair and the mark up for ammo isn't as high as other places for exotic or niche ammo. For example hallow point .223 are only 4 to 5 dollars more than other online based retailers. That's a steal considering you can physically see and inspect the rounds before you buy'em.”

“Very friendly staff and great selection of firearms. After looking around today I can confidently say these guys had the best deals out of everywhere i’ve shopped at. Would recommend this place to anyone, I will definitely be back!”

“Great place to get advice and purchase your quality firearms. Bought a S&W 38 pistol and holster from them a few years ago and the pistol is worth twice today than what I paid for it from them. If you read all of the reviews, those who gave bad reviews were either looking to buy cheap ammo, or they have big egos and think they know more about guns than the owner.They don't. The place is called Classic Firearms for a reason...not ammo depot or Bass Pro Shop.”

“I’ve been coming to The Point at Carlisle Plaza for roughly three decades, since I was around 10 years old, back when this shopping center was actually thriving, so there’s definitely some nostalgia walking through here.

These days, a lot of the plaza sits vacant, but Dunham’s is honestly one of the anchor stores helping keep this place alive, and after this visit, it’s easy to see why.

If you’ve never been inside this location, don’t assume it’s just a small sporting goods store.

This place is surprisingly packed with inventory across a huge range of categories. On this visit alone I walked through departments for footwear, athletic apparel, fitness equipment, dumbbells, kettlebells, treadmills, golf clubs and accessories, fishing gear, hunting gear, firearms, ammunition, archery, safes, tactical apparel, YETI drinkware, Owala bottles, Black Rifle Coffee products, coolers, cornhole sets, kayaks, paddle gear, boots, kids sports equipment, sunglasses, bags, and more.

The biggest thing that stood out to me was how clean, organized, and well lit the store is.

For the amount of inventory they carry, it never felt cluttered or chaotic. Departments are clearly laid out, aisles are easy to navigate, and it’s actually simple to find what you’re looking for even if you’re just browsing.

That matters.

We checked out with Rudy, who was excellent. Friendly, efficient, and professional. The other team members we interacted with were also helpful without hovering or being pushy, which I appreciate.

One constructive note, because first impressions matter:

The exterior Dunham’s storefront sign needs attention. Several letters/lights are burned out, and when your business name is the very first thing customers see, that should be top priority. The inside experience says clean, organized, and professionally run. The exterior branding should match that same standard.

That said, this is still an easy 5 star review.

If you’re in the Carlisle area and need sporting goods, fitness gear, fishing equipment, hunting supplies, footwear, or outdoor recreation products, this location is absolutely worth the stop.”