Madcap & Co. is a charming gift shop located in the heart of downtown Lancaster’s shopping district on North Queen Street. It offers a wide variety of unique, fun, and quirky gifts, making it a popular spot for visitors and locals alike. The store features a nostalgic selection at its retro candy counter and is an exclusive retailer of Lucky Mfg Co. merchandise. Customers appreciate the friendly and helpful customer service, as well as the reward punchcard system, which adds a fun element to shopping. The shop is known for its local Lancaster merchandise, fair trade, and USA-made products, along with cards that often make people laugh. Many visitors enjoy finding cute and one-of-a-kind gifts for loved ones, with reviews highlighting the store’s high-quality products and modern feel. The shop is LGBTQ friendly and offers a variety of gift options suitable for all occasions. While some find the price tags difficult to remove from certain items, overall, Madcap & Co. is considered a delightful and worth-visit destination for gift shopping in Lancaster.
this was my favorite store out there. i got a schitts creek tee, some pens, and bath soak. so many fun items i could go nuts in here lol. very nice staff too.
May 2026
As a local this is always a go to! There are many odd and unique gifts and products you can find as well as some great homemade ones. Super sweet staff who was the kindest and chatted me up while I checked out. Definitely recommend!
April 2026
Super cool store and items, just staff wasn’t very friendly.
