Jewelry Stores in Lancaster, PA

29 locations found near Lancaster

“We have always shopped at Brent L. I cannot say enough good about them.

Pam and Candace have worked with us on some custom pieces that are truly bespoke, and heirloom in quality, she has always been incredibly warm, knowledgeable and accommodating.

I also cannot say enough good things about Marissa. She is so sweet and welcoming, and always delivers truly personalized service, and always with a smile. She helped us tremendously with the coordination of a watch repair that was very sentimental.

And what would Brent be without Jo? She is magnetic and always ready with a smile and a recommendation. 😉”

5 Superb281 Reviews

“Entire staff is attentive and courteous and very helpful. I had a custom pendant made and it was beautiful. I also had repair and resizing work done and everything was given the utmost care regardless of value. Definitely our new go to jewelry store.”

5 Superb174 Reviews

“Wen was absolutely amazing! She helped me choose the perfect watch for a very important wedding, and I couldn’t be happier with my experience. She was patient, knowledgeable, and genuinely cared about helping me find something that was just right. She made the whole process easy and enjoyable, and I never felt rushed or pressured. Her excellent customer service made a special occasion even more memorable. Thank you, Wen. I highly recommend asking for her if you visit Reeds Jewelry!”

4.9 Superb279 Reviews

“My family has been going to Ream Jewelers for decades, and there’s a reason we’ve continued to trust them through the years. They consistently provide outstanding customer service, honest advice, and an unmatched level of knowledge and expertise.

Whether you’re purchasing a special piece of jewelry, a watch, or having something repaired, they treat you like family and take the time to answer every question without ever making you feel pressured. Their professionalism, integrity, and genuine care for their customers are evident every time you walk through the door.

It’s rare to find a business with such a long history of serving the community while maintaining the same high standards and personal touch. Ream Jewelers has earned our family’s trust over generations, and I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend them to anyone looking for exceptional quality, expert guidance, and a truly enjoyable experience.”

5 Superb191 Reviews

“Walked in wearing a t-shirt and shorts and received a warm welcome and friendly service.
They listened to what I was looking for and showed me both the new and estate pieces they had in stock.
Prices were fair and the gemstone quality they offered, was better than some of the other pieces we saw at other retailers. lf we had any questions or wanted more than one opinion, all the staff were happy to help.
Before we left they made sure the pieces were clean.
100% recommend seeing what they have to offer before making a purchase.”

5 Superb176 Reviews

“I wish there was a way to give more than 5 ☆ because they treat customers with great respect. Explain every detail about any questions you may have and are very attentive to listen to what your needs are.
The ladies today were just amazing to work with!

Highly recommend this store 👏 and I will definitely come back to do business with them 🤩”

4.9 Superb172 Reviews

“I had a great experience at Dave's. Excellent customer service with a wonderful smile and positive energy. If you are in the Lancaster area, drop by and visit this a amazing store.”

4.9 Superb164 Reviews

“This place is a great way to spend an afternoon. We were lucky enough to snag a walk-in spot, but you can also make reservations and book small parties. This would be a great activity for an older kid birthday or a bachelorette party. The whole experience was super affordable and the staff were so helpful. My necklace cost $11 and my friend’s bracelet with freshwater pearls came out to about $15. I’ll definitely be back!”

4.9 Superb130 Reviews

“Finch Jewelers gave me a fantastic experience, I was able to send them sample photos of engagement rings i had looked at online and they had samples that were identical and high quality available to review in store for me the same week.

They were also able to set the stone and have it ready for pick up same day for a last minute surprise proposal on valentines day. All around great people to work with.”

4.9 Superb162 Reviews

“My now fiancé and I came to Reeds to custom design my engagement ring and wedding band. The whole process was so smooth and SO exciting to do together. Chelsea was a DREAM at helping bring this ring to life and through the whole process was focused on us and our goals, and so supportive. Our experience with Reeds was top notch and so intentional. We couldn’t have asked for more. THANK YOU!”

4.8 Superb206 Reviews

“Aaliyah the store rep was very patient with me! She was professional and very informative with the anniversary purchase from my husband! We will definitely recommend her to all our family and friends!”

4.8 Superb222 Reviews

“Stopped at Kay Jewlers @ Tanger Outlets to upgrade my wife's wedding ring. Skylar's attention to detail was first class, she knew exactly what we were looking for and made the transaction seamless.
Thanks so much !!”

4.7 Superb155 Reviews

“I worked with Journey to design a custom ring and had an absolutely awesome experience. She took the time to know me, my story, and incorporated meaningful elements into a beautiful piece that I absolutely love! She was incredibly receptive to feedback, pivoted when we needed to make changes to keep the piece within my price point, and the outcome is a ring that I will always cherish! Highly, highly recommend!”

4.8 Superb63 Reviews

“My wife and I were looking for custom wedding rings. From the moment we walked in, Andrea made us feel like life-long friends. She helped us narrow down exactly what we were looking for, and Jude made us both beautiful pieces that we will cherish for the rest of our lives. We can not say enough great things about them! Very knowledgeable in what they do, highly recommend!”

5 Superb22 Reviews

“From Tennessee, was in Lancaster, visiting family there. Went in to Madcap & Co since it came up on my search results for souvenirs to get some cute gifts for other family members. Fun shop with all kinds of neat ideas and gifts!”

4.7 Superb88 Reviews

“✨❤️ My daughters and I ran to Twin Falls in hopes that Ooh Lala would have a dress that I could wear to a wedding the next day!! Liyah, the owner, was so helpful. She listened to what my vision was and had the perfect dress. She also had the most perfect dresses for a wedding in New York my daughter and I need to attend in October. This store has style, grace, originality, and Liyah is like the goddess of Venus. Offering beauty and luxury to the world. ✨❤️ I am so happy we stopped in. ✨ This level of customer service and quality of clothing cannot be found in a big box store. ✨❤️ This was such a pleasant visit, Liyah thank you for sharing with us. You have a customer for life . ❤️✨ Love, Rose”

4.7 Superb49 Reviews

“I always try to stop by this coin shop whenever I'm driving through Lancaster. Owner and employee I usually see there are both very friendly and I always hear him explaining coins, collecting, and pricing to his customers. Especially kind to kids learning to collect. Great variety to look through and they're always patient with me even though I'm not a big buyer and I take WAY too much time browsing;). Fair pricing buying & selling and everything you could want in a coin shop.
If you're looking for a coin shop in Lancaster, don't waste your time with the other ones(I already checked them out for you). Go to this one & you can thank me later:).”

4.6 Superb101 Reviews

“Very cool selection. Smells nice in there too with the incense burning. Bought some very cozy clothes and looked at some cool minerals. Will definitely come back!”

4.6 Superb94 Reviews

“I have been going here for all my jewelry since I was 9 years old, and now my kids have pieces from here. Def family more than anything. Pete is your go to guy for all your custom made pieces.”

4.6 Superb49 Reviews

“What an awesome experience it was to come to Filling's Clothing and get fitted for a suit. This was 5 Stars from top to bottom. Randy, and the entire staff made me feel cared for. Everyone was willing to go the extra mile to make sure that I was rocking a seriously wonderful suit but making me look good to boot! I got the full treatment from shirt, to tie, to a bespoke suit and all the accoutrements!

Thank you so much for your dedication and attention to detail. The quality shines through in your products and your service.”

4.5 Superb45 Reviews

“With comfortable being the most important for me, I was so pleased to find offerings that are both comfortable and fashionable. For the fashionably challenged like myself, it helps to have the excellent customer service Sue offers, from how to wear things, little tips and pairing suggestions. Thanks!”

4.2 Good16 Reviews

“They fixed my son's graduation ring because I mistakenly sent the wrong size to the manufacturer and we it came didn't fit in his finger. Well we brought the ring to their store and they fixed it in three days. The job done was amazing. You can't notice it was repaired. I recommend them to anyone looking to get a job well done. The customer service also was very good. Thank you guys . I really appreciate your professionalism.”

4.3 Superb21 Reviews

“Melinda was an amazing sales person. Went to another Jeweler that didn’t pay us any attention and when we went over to zales Melinda helped us right away. If I could get more than five stars, I would.”

4.5 Superb96 Reviews

“I googled for estate jewelry and they came up, I had business in Lancaster so I stopped in, very glad I did. I love Estate jewelry and their cases have all kinds of beautiful pieces. They also have a room that has sterling silver jewelry as well. The two ladies were helpful and friendly.
I found the pricing extremely reasonable , I bought three rings.
If you are looking for reasonable, one of a kind jewelry, please stop in.”

4.2 Good47 Reviews

“We cannot recommend Oletowne Jewelers enough!

John and his wife were incredibly kind and helpful throughout the entire process.

I was looking to create a custom wedding band that would fit flush with my engagement ring, and John went above and beyond to offer thoughtful solutions and design options—all at a very reasonable price.

We’re absolutely planning to return for any future jewelry needs. Thank you again for such a wonderful experience!”

4.3 Superb105 Reviews

“Brittany was an amazing help. Came in to get battery replaced and she was very kind and helpful. I would definitely return here because of her kindness and generosity.”

3.8 Good34 Reviews

“JASMIN! She was so INCREDIBLY kind and helpful. I had gone to over 6 different Banter locations to try and find my necklace that had broke. When I explained to her the situation, she immediately sprang to action to try and help me get it, as she could tell how much it meant to me. Because I had the protection plan, I was able to get a replacement but was told I could only replace it if i could find it at a location (which i couldn’t). Jasmin ensured i would get it and helped with the entire process. She was real, kind, energetic, and bubbly. If you have any need to go to Banter, check out the Park city location in Lancaster !”

4.2 Good77 Reviews

“We've been here a couple of times, most recently to buy a gift for our grandmother's birthday. The lady at the front was super nice. She showed us how to make something personal and customized in just a few minutes.

Additionally, she brought out crayons for our kids to play with while we were going through the process. It could not have been more pleasant and my grandmother was blown away by the results. Also, the ability to actually draw and have the machine engrave it exactly is a huge bonus. I thought that was super cool and added a really nice touch.

All in all, I can say I'll definitely coming back if we ever need more charms!”

4 Good80 Reviews

“The women at this store are incredible to work with! I was looking for a solid yellow gold rope chain and Jaz helped me find one that was not only the perfect length but a great price! I will definitely shop here again!”

3.5 Good37 Reviews