Plato's Closet of Monroeville is a recycling retail store that focuses on trendy name brand casual wear for teens and young adults. The store specializes in gently used clothes, shoes, handbags, and accessories that are no more than 12-18 months old. Customers can sell their clothing any day, without an appointment, and receive cash on the spot. The store adds fresh inventory daily and offers popular styles at up to 70% off regular mall prices. While some customers appreciate the good selection and affordable prices, others have faced challenges with selling their items, particularly when newer clothes with tags were not accepted. The store is noted to be clean and organized, with friendly staff who are willing to help. However, some reviewers expressed frustration over unclear pricing and the limited availability of certain items, like skirts. Despite these concerns, many customers enjoy shopping at this location, even traveling from nearby areas for the friendly service and better buyback rates compared to other stores.
IMO this store is well organized, clean, and has a nice selection of clothes and shoes. My teenage daughter found several things she was excited to buy. Also, the staff were welcoming and friendly, which is always appreciated. Thanks Platos, we will definitely be back :)
April 2026
Staff was super friendly and they hav a bunch of options for anyone's personal style or preference. Had some really great finds today!
September 2025
Charged me twice due to a weird network issue when checking out at the register. Sales associate and I didn’t know at the time, of course. The reason for the 2stars is that they are of no help with giving me back my money. Donated $60 to Plato’s, I guess.
