Blue Mountain Thrift Store has garnered mixed reviews from customers. Many appreciate the store's friendly staff and clean environment, as well as the good variety and quality of clothing. Some shoppers find the prices slightly higher than other thrift shops, but many believe the selection is worth it. One customer even noted finding vintage toys at a fraction of their eBay prices, highlighting the store’s potential for great deals.
However, others have expressed disappointment with rising prices and a decline in merchandise quality. Several reviews mention that prices have increased significantly, making new items from retailers like Target and Walmart more affordable. This shift has left some longtime customers feeling disheartened, as they remember a time when the store offered fair prices and a more organized shopping experience.
Additionally, there have been comments regarding service, with one customer initially facing issues but later receiving a follow-up call that resolved the situation. Overall, Blue Mountain Thrift Store is praised for its friendly atmosphere and potential finds, but it also faces criticism for its pricing and recent changes in merchandise quality.
Stopped here awhile back late at night on the way home. Alot to look at. Very clean and organized which made looking threw easier. Planning another trip out that way soon.
June 2026
Huge store - lots of NWT and brand name items. Don’t let the reviews about that scare you – most of the items were reasonably priced unless they were expensive brands or brand new. There’s a huge selection so it’s wasn’t an issue for me.
May 2026
The displays are very nice and staff were kind and helpful! I found a lot of great things at very good prices!
