Wagner Shoes, established in 1854 on Butler Street, has built a long-standing reputation for quality footwear and excellent customer service over six generations. The store offers a wide selection of leading footwear brands such as Hoka, Birkenstock, New Balance, On Running, Brooks, and more, available in various sizes and widths. Customers are greeted by knowledgeable staff who take the time to properly measure and scan their feet, ensuring a perfect fit. The store also provides custom orthotics and leather stretching to help with foot comfort and ease of breaking in new shoes. Reviews highlight the attentive and friendly service provided by staff, with one customer noting that they were helped in choosing the right orthotics to eliminate foot pain, and others appreciating the thorough fitting process and personalized attention. Many visitors mention their positive experiences during special events like small business Saturday, and some express their intention to return for future purchases. Customers also value the store’s dedication to individual needs, with staff asking questions about fit, feel, and style to ensure satisfaction. Overall, Wagner Shoes is recognized for its friendly, attentive service and wide selection of quality footwear, making it a trusted destination for those seeking well-fitted and comfortable shoes.
We love Wagner's! Excellent customer service and quality items for sustainable foot support. I highly recommend getting custom inserts for your shoes using their digital high tech scanner. It's a health professionals dream!
June 2026
Amazing experience. Super helpful crew. Such a superior experience than order online or in a big store.
May 2026
I came with my mother and Mitch made it a wonderful experience! So grateful for the service and patience!
