McCarthy Tire Service receives reviews noting both positive experiences and recent concerns. Many customers describe having an absolutely fantastic experience, praising the team as very friendly and very professional. They highlight perfect communication, reasonable prices, and a willingness to accommodate appointments. Customers report feeling well taken care of and highly recommend them for tire needs and other work. However, a long-term customer notes the place has started to go downhill over the past year. Concerns include customer service that is no longer there, described as very short and impatient. There are reports of requested work not being done and a decline in maintaining vehicle cleanliness, with issues like greasy residues left behind. The reviewer hopes service quality improves, as it was good in the past.
I was going away for weekend and had a leak in my tire. They helped me out the day before and fixed it. Very friendly and professional. Definitely recommend and I will be back.
June 2026
We had a great experience and their staff are very friendly. They got us in right away
February 2026
I havn’t been in for a service, yet, but I did meet a very helpful gentleman, today, from McCarthy. I was a little frustrated and stumped at the Rutter’s air tank, with a lot of questions; when one of your guys pulled up at the perfect time. He answered my questions, and was very kind. Thank you stranger!
