Pizza Mill offers an exceptional dining experience, serving incredible food with perfect portions of dough, cheese, and sauce. The crust is light, crispy, and fluffy, while the breadsticks are simply amazing. The menu boasts a wide variety of pizzas, including classic favorites like pepperoni, cheese, and supreme. The restaurant features a cozy seating area, with some extra seating available outside, and a selection of local beers. Prices are reasonable, and the overall dining experience is excellent. Customers consistently praise the fantastic pizza and salad, as well as the cleanliness of the establishment, including the bathrooms. Pizza Mill is a great spot to enjoy a delicious meal after a long day in the Black Hills. The staff is friendly and welcoming, providing a memorable dining experience. The restaurant is known for its high-quality ingredients and attention to detail, making it a local favorite.
If we could, we would give them more than 5 stars! Food is phenomenal! Service is AMAZING!!! Best place to eat in Custer! Laid back, chill, delicious!!!
June 2026
The pizza was AMAZING! We are from Canada and this is the best pizza we have had in the US. Everything about it was perfect 🤤
June 2026
We had 14 pizzas delivered for our daughter’s wedding . Owner was very friendly, helpful ,and communicated well. Everyone was very impressed with the pizzas ! They were delicious! Thank you !
