We definitely recommend the Pizza Mill!! It is a great family operated business with awesome food and friendly staff! We don’t live in Custer, but when we make it there we are sure to hit up Pizza Mill.
Phone was busy so we just drove over. They took great care of us and the food was wonderful. We got so much we even had pizza for breakfast the next morning.
I'm from Chicago and New York. This is neither kind of pizza. But then we're in South Dakota. Not my expectations for pizza That said we'd expected left overs, but we ate the whole thing. Also delivered before promised. Satisfied plus. Yeah go ahead and get some.
Pizza was as good as it looks. We had the Timber ???? Pizza. It was great and the crust was perfect. Enjoyed eating on the deck and watching the sun set. Only on Custer for a few days, but anxious to try something else from here before we leave.