September 2020 by DowneastCornhusker
Very nice and easy to order over the phone. Understood our desire to wait in our car until the pizza was ready. Food was very good as well.
September 2020 by T T.
Salad was decent but pizza was a big no for me. No different than Digiorno. Really nice people working there though.
August 2020 by James W.
I can't believe we lucked out with this place! Such amazing service from the girl working... everything! And such good pizza!! The crust was on point, the sauce was hearty and good, and the price was fair. If you're it then area sightseeing go get a 'za from this place! A little further down the road and oh so good. Yelp reviews did it again!!
August 2020 by Ernest Go
A hidden gem tuck away in a small town off 16A West just right out of Custer State Park. Great pizza!
August 2020 by Rachael Grainger
This place is so good! We stopped here on the way through South Dakota and had three different pizzas. I recommend the sun dried tomatoes on pizza. The server was so helpful and nice!
August 2020 by Matt
Grab a quick bit of some great tasting pizza at this place after a long day of hiking at Custer. The staff is very friendly and the pizza is on point. Its a nice change of pace from the other restaurants in the area. Cozy interior with additional seating outside.
August 2020 by desiprincess
My husband and I were blown away by this place. Kids loved it too! Maybe the best pizza I have ever had in my entire life. The braided crust was incredible, and it was quite reasonably priced.
August 2020 by lovetime2vacation
Glad we asked around town for the best pizza. They did not lead us astray! Great pizza and friendly staff!
August 2020 by Rhoderic M.
Here to visit Mount Rushmore, the wife and I were looking for somewhere to eat that wasn't the same old food as back home. We found this place on yelp and I will say this is great pizza. Wife rated it a 7.8 and I rated it an 8.2. It was great. Even great service! Best pepperoni pizza I've had in a long time.
August 2020 by Connie B.
Good pizza. Unique crust. Clean place and fast, courteous service. Everyone agreed it was better than our favorite pizza place back home.
August 2020 by carrieowns
Pizza Mill never disappoints!! Their ingredients are so fresh. And the pizzas are really fun named! I recommend the Reuben Pizza.
July 2020 by DillonM1905
We ordered for takeout and got our pizza in about 20 minutes. It tasted great and the prices were reasonable. Service was friendly and fast. I would stop again.
July 2020 by Stephanie Marden
Pizza was delicious. The onion rings were super scrumptious! Definitely recommend. They get super busy but it's worth the wait.
July 2020 by Zarhie I
What a quaint, comfortable, DELICIOUS place! We were passing through and especially pleased with the quality of their pizza. Green olives on a chicken barbecue pizza? Who woulda thought? Yummy! I am going to need someone to open a pizza mill by my house, in Utah, please!
July 2020 by Stacy Maxted
We built our own pizza on the gluten free crust. They put ranch on for the sauce and it was amazing! Best gluten free crust I've ever had!
July 2020 by Shilow Smith
Best gluten free pizza ever!!! They do not go light on the cheese and topping!!! The regular pizza has an amazing thick crust around the edge that you can dip in honey. The sauce on the pizza is sweet and delicious. A must place to stop!! The lady that took our order was so kind and checked on us a couple of times. Five stars all the way!!!
July 2020 by Cindy C U later
Great place! We were visiting SD and stayed close to this pizza place. Ended up ordering from twice in a short 3 day stay. Great sandwiches and great pizza. Cashier was super friendly.
July 2020 by Jason Thompson
Love a great cheese, amazing crust, and friendly employees? This is the place for you. Come for the pizza and get something unique in this town.
July 2020 by Subarna Bhattachan
This pizza shop has really good thin crust pizza with braided sides. They were real busy but they managed to get the food out in time. The young server behind the counter was polite & friendly. He was working real hard to get things done. They have a nice patio with a mill saws & corrugated tin rustic interior inside. This place delivers good marks in spite of the tiny location. Good job team & thank you.
July 2020 by Joel Wallen
Great little find. I highly recommend the calzones. They are super huge though so I’d recommend sharing.
June 2020 by BigTool
Not much to say, it was a good pie. We would get pizza from here again during our next stay in Custer.
June 2020 by Brian L
It’s pizza. They are abiding by social distance norms which is nice
June 2020 by Sherri
Pizza and garlic cheese bread were delicious! The staff was very friendly, and our food came out quick. Thank you!
June 2020 by Cevera S.
Crispy pizza and very good pizza sauce with delicious toppings. Very friendly and helpful person who took our order. Overall good pizza that wasn't too expensive. I do not recommend the cheesy bread with cheese. Pretty much texted toast with very little cheese.
June 2020 by Katie H.
Great crust and toppings! Our pizza was very hot too! The only reason I didn't give it 5 stars is that I like a tangy sauce and this was sweet, but still good.
June 2020 by Jason N.
On the advice of the waitress at Mount Rushmore brewing we went. My son got the ham and cheese hot sandwich and wife and I split the tower pizza...everything is fresh and tasty...very little grease and honestly a great spot to escape tourist trap pizza in Custer!
June 2020 by Shellie Long
This place is amazing. So friendly and the pizza crust is the most perfect I have tasted in many years. It has been a different experience traveling in this state during this time. The staff at the Pizza Mill was very welcoming to us unlike a lot of places in this area. Which is crazy cause I know they depend on tourism.
June 2020 by Sam Handschke
The food is varied and excellent. My wife picked it up, so I can't speak to the interior or staff interaction. We had the supreme (loaded with everything). The flavors meld together in a way I hadn't experienced before. It causes an overall delicious taste that transcends the individual ingredients. For example, the pizza had a few things that I don't like, but I didn't realize this until I was almost done with my second slice. The flavor composition was perfectly balanced. The crust is thin-ish underneath and folded up at the edges. It should appeal to both thin and thick crust fans. Leftovers heat up pretty well in the microwave, so do not be afraid of getting more than you can eat.
May 2020 by Suzie S.
We vote this place a 4.5/5stars. Pricing was comparable to the other small place in town with equally fast service & friendly staff. Ingredients seemed equally as fresh here and we liked the flavor but liked the other pizza place better. Solid 4.5 from us.
May 2020 by Jackie J.
This little pizza place is the best around! While in the RV and from out of town, we love trying the local places! One, it supports the small businesses and not the chains. Two, you're likely to get a great surprise and try something you've never had! The pizza here was fabulous! Lots of options and all is fresh and homemade! Best crust ever!!!! And a Greek Gyro pizza? Yup. Amazing. It's so much worth spending a little extra- you get extra! And the staff was polite, friendly, helpful, and funny! If e are ever back in Custer, SD, we will eat here! Go. You won't be sorry!