-
March 2024 by David Cristina
Everything was so yummy! Great place!! 10/10 will be back!
-
March 2024 by Changes to your name will be reflected across
Pizza was a solid 3 stars. Very cheese and crust was decent for a small pizza joint. The sauce was good but very much lacking. Definitely order with extra sauce. Atmosphere and staff were nice! Decent beer choice!
-
February 2024 by Aimee Anderson
Favorite pizza in town they always have great toppings, and the crust is delicious too. I've been a regular since moving to Custer.
-
January 2024 by Debi Chavez
Didn’t feel like cooking so ordered Pizza Mill. We ordered Chicken Alfredo and a Reuben Sandwich with onion rings and a side salad. Delicious!!! The salad was fresh, my husband really enjoyed the Reuben and the Alfredo was extremely good. In the past we’ve also had their pizzas, the Towering Timber was delicious!!The service was also great.Debi
-
December 2023 by Seamo Sho
I love the garlic bread served with pasta. Pizza also nice!!
-
November 2023 by Jocelyn Zon
This was the best pizza I have ever had, absolutely amazing, If I am ever in this town I would stop here for more food.
-
November 2023 by Julie Moe
Stopped in for lunch and we each ordered a personal pan pizza. This was by far the best pizza I have ever had. That crust is perfectly cooked and hand made with quality ingredients for the toppings. I had the ponderosa and it had just the right kick of flavors. The personal pan is quite big but I ate it all just because it was that good. Highly Recommend!!!!
-
November 2023 by Leslie Hadash
Great little pizza place in Custer. The pizza is super cheesy, toppings are fresh and delicious, and the gluten-free crust is good, too! There is room to dine in or take out.
-
October 2023 by Eric
Some of the best pizza we've ever had, and we're from New York!
-
October 2023 by Sean Steel (budershank)
Great traditional and non-traditional pizza. A reuben pizza? Count me in. Cheese bread was very generous cheese wise. We also used the outdoor sitting since we had a dog. If we were staying in the area longer, we would eat here again.
-
September 2023 by Anthony Prentice
The pizza is exceptional. Fresh ingredients and an authentic well put together crust. I’m not easily impressed yet I am impressed by The Mill Pizza’s pizza.
-
September 2023 by Chrystal Penner
The pizza we got for take out was absolutely delicious. It is so delectable and such a good change from the regular run of the mill pizza places. We loved it?
-
September 2023 by wiminneapolis
Stop here while I’m our way to Custer State Park; it is small place with couple tables outside; pizza was very good; all ingredients tasted fresh ; had the Supreme; it was thin crust with thicker edge Great service
-
August 2023 by Voyager16572606651
Great crust!! We liked everything about Pizza Mill! Their ingredients we fresh and delicious and the customer service was delightful!
-
August 2023 by xXkatieXx
Very good pizza!!! (Also very good is Cruizzers in Keystone, SD)The crust is slightly sweet and once you eat the pizza, leave the crust…you can put the honey (that they offer) on the crust and it makes a very good dessert!!!
