This Casey's location offers pizza delivery and pickup with made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings. It also provides appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, groceries, and household essentials, along with quality fuels. Reviews note the pizza is almost always past the time, leaving it overcooked and dry. The fountain soda was flat and nasty. Food quality can be inconsistent, with barbecue sliders sometimes great and sometimes dry. However, the jalapeño peanuts are always awesome. The store is clean. Staff experiences vary: a cashier was nice and one manager handled a rush like a rock star, remaining calm and professional. Other times, the staff is often rude, with reports of poor service. The location has some work to do, but some recent night staff have been praised for turning the store around for the better.
The pizza is great, but the condiments are always well past their shelf life. The Cholula packets taste sour and the parmesan cheese packets are like sawdust.
May 2025
Ordered thin crust pizza cut into squares. Told it would be 10 minutes. 30 minutes later it came out not thin crust and not cut into squares. I took it anyway and when I got home the middle of the pizza was cold. I won't order there again
June 2024
I had your barbecue sliders one time and they were great and they sucked the second time. Pulled pork shavings are dry. The jalapeño peanuts are always awesome.
