Casey's in Sioux Falls, SD at 3840 W Benson Rd is a versatile convenience spot offering great pizza, snacks, drinks, groceries, and fuel. Known for their made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings, the pizza is a popular choice for delivery and pickup. Customers appreciate the good quality and reasonable prices, especially for pizza, making it a reliable go-to. However, some reviews mention issues with late orders, particularly during busy times. One customer scheduled an order two hours ahead but experienced a delay of 25 minutes past the expected time, with staff citing short staffing as the reason. This led to disappointment, as the order was not ready on time, and no apology was given. The location also offers a car wash, which receives positive feedback for its quality. In particular, the manager, who is described as wonderful and helpful, made a strong impression on customers. One customer, who drove three hours just to use the car wash, praised the service received from the manager and considered this a 5-star experience overall. Additionally, customers highlight friendly staff, especially at the gas station, with one noting excellent treatment from an employee who went above and beyond during a problem with the diesel pump. Food items like breakfast pizza are also well-liked, with one customer noting it was better than previous experiences and planning to order more in the future if quality remains consistent. Overall, Casey's is valued for its pizza, friendly service, and convenient amenities, despite some occasional delays.
They charge for air. What happened to the king of the Midwest gas stations? Their fall has been meteoric. Skip Casey's and head to the Kwik Star on Madison instead
September 2025
Definitely missing the brand mark casey usually provides..
August 2025
Large coffee is constantly only 16oz and online it states 20oz. Took a cup home just to measure. I even press the fill cup selection. I shown it to a worker and she said that is the correct amount. Won't go there anymore. Looking for a new place for coffee and breakfast snack.
