-
November 2023 by Cheryl Sanders
I sampled and bought the butterscotch peanut butter. Divine. Also the chipped nutter butters candy. Love it.
-
November 2023 by Nada Huff
I bought the sweet cinnamon peanut butter and it is amazing!! I will definitely be back to buy more!
-
July 2023 by Amanda Cole
Stopped at this little store today for the very first time. The owner was very sweet. I taste tested her white chocolate peanut butter and I fell in love instantly and bought a jar, plus many other sweets. Brownies, rice crispies, fudge, etc. This place is a must!
-
May 2023 by Chelsey H
Great little stop if you love peanut butter! There’s several selections of peanut butter flavors to choose from, you can also taste test them to find your favorites before you purchase. They have some other treats such as candy, ice cream, cookies, etc.
-
January 2023 by Ann Hall
We drove to Jefferson to buy peanut butter as stocking stuffers for Christmas. Our family loved it! We bought a variety and they were all a big hit. The owner was very nice and helpful. We’ll be back to buy more!
-
January 2023 by Susan O'Donnell
Fantastic products and owner is extremely friendly and knowledgeable not only about the store, but about whole town.
-
January 2023 by R C
Staff is always friendly. We drive an hour to buy their fresh made peanut butter.
-
December 2022 by Janet C
Staff is always friendly. We drive an hour to buy their fresh made peanut butter.
-
July 2022 by Julia Sullivan
This place was so fun. You can sample all of the flavors and they all are delicious. Owner is super friendly. Definitely recommend if you're in town!
-
July 2022 by Heather Pahlman
Love this place! I went this weekend the only place I want to buy peanut butter now!
-
April 2022 by Katie Roberson
Holy smokes. Never in my life have I ever had peanut butter this good. Literally made by the hands of Jesus himself. Lights gleam each time my husband and I open the jar. Spoons jump from our kitchen drawers. It’s a must-have!!!!!!!!!
-
March 2022 by Kelly O.
Yum!!! You can sample all their nut butters. So many tasty flavors it's hard to pick just one!!! I am a peanut butter lover so this place spoke to me! I left with lots of goodies: Nut butter, cake balls, chocolate covered things etc. I'm glad there is not one closer to me or I would be in trouble!!! Everything I tried and bought was super delicious!! You must stop if you're in the area!
-
January 2022 by Pam Phillips
Went to Nutty’s to try the Sugar free with Sea Salt and blown away how it tasted. It tasted like just peanuts. Not hard to stir or spread like store-bought natural peanut butters. I shared Nutty’s info with a keto group I’m in. Think I’ll go scoop a spoon now
-
December 2021 by Theresa Stutzman
The best homemade peanut butter in the world ! Lovely couple who take pride in the many different peanut butter flavors - and nostalgic cute store you can buy all things peanut butter !
-
December 2021 by Robert L Russo Jr.
Amazing gentleman behind the counter. Fresh samples. The best peanut butter I’ve ever had
