Shetler Fine Jewelers is a fine jewelry store offering the highest quality of customer service since 2005. Home to an expertly curated assortment of exceptional fine jewelry, they boast a high standard of excellence. In 2021, Shetler Fine Jewelers acquired Medlar Jewel Masters, resulting in the addition of two master jewelers and an onsite custom designer. Alongside the existing sales and design staff, the acquisition created a combined bench jewelry experience spanning over 120 years. Shetler specializes in custom jewelry creation, offers an unparalleled bridal experience, and features a wide array of designers such as Armenta, JB Star, Jude Frances, Kwiat, Penny Preville, and Temple St. Clair. Customers praise the store's exceptional customer service, compassion, and caring, with staff being described as helpful, patient, and attentive. Specific employees, such as Britney, Marissa, and Robin, have been highlighted for their outstanding service and attention to detail. Customers have had positive experiences with Shetler, whether it's resizing and redesigning heirloom jewelry, creating custom engagement rings, or simply browsing the store's selection. The store's commitment to excellence, expertise, and personalized care has earned it a loyal customer base and a reputation for being a trusted source for fine jewelry.
These folks knocked my ring outta the park! Their team of master jewlers are some of the best in the business. I entrusted them to make my wedding ring and re-style a family heirloom. And I get compliments everywhere I go.
May 2026
Very friendly, great customer service. Beautiful store with so many pretty baubles!!
May 2026
The jewelers are exceptional. They definitely go above, and beyond their work is exquisite! Jalisa is very talented and accommodating.
