ME & My Pets is a trusted neighborhood pet store known for its great value, quality products, and friendly, knowledgeable staff. Customers appreciate the wide selection of items for all types of pets, including healthy food options with hundreds of choices. The staff provide helpful advice on pet care and products, making it easy for pet owners to find what they need, such as ear cleaners for kittens or specialized pet food. The owner is highly praised for being kind, respectful, and well-informed about pet nutrition, often assisting customers in making better choices for their pets’ health. The store also fosters dogs in need of temporary homes, reflecting its caring community spirit. Many customers have been shopping there for years, benefiting from good service, reasonable prices, and frequent sales. Despite some negative reviews, visitors highlight the respectful treatment they received, emphasizing that the shop is a welcoming place for pet owners who want the best for their animals. Overall, ME & My Pets is considered the best pet store in the Fort Atkinson area, a place where both pets and their owners feel valued and well cared for.
Great prices, and very helpful! We bought a cat tower that was easily a $200 item for $100. Staff was knowledgeable about ingredients and various cat products. We came in with two new kittens, and they hooked us up for a great price and a smile.
July 2026
Thank you Scott and team for being so helpful, kind, and welcoming! During our time at ME and My pets there was a strong community presence. We thank Scott for his partnerships in the community and supporting animals in need!
June 2026
Cute little shop. Big variety of cat and dog foods. Kind workers, very knowledgeable.
