Price's Collectibles, located in Historic Downtown Greendale, WI, has been a one‑stop shop for sports cards and memorabilia since 1989. The store offers a great selection of vintage cards, unopened boxes, and PSA or SGC grading services. It also buys collections of sports cards, memorabilia, vintage toys, Star Wars items, and vintage advertising signs. Customers praise the friendly, helpful, and knowledgeable staff, who make shopping enjoyable and provide great service. The shop is known for its great selection of wax and singles and for easy PSA grading drop‑off. Overall, visitors love the shop’s great service, great selection, and the passion for the hobby that makes every visit fun.
Jeff is friendly and knowledgeable. I will continue to go back to him for PSA submissions and other trading cards needs.
May 2026
It is one of the few/last community card shop stores in Milwaukee. I enjoyed meeting people talking about the hobby and talking to Jeff about history of the cards. I am lucky to have found it. Prices are very reasonable and he always gives you a good deal
May 2026
I’ve been coming to this shop for a while now, and it’s easily one of the best spots around. Inventory is always changing, and it’s just a fun place to hang out and talk cards. Whether you’re a serious collector or just getting started, this shop is definitely worth stopping by. Highly recommend!
