Jewelry Stores in Lake Geneva, WI

12 locations found near Lake Geneva

“Got my jewelry cleaned for free!! She did an AMAZING job my earrings look brand new! Did not know I could even bring outside jewelry to key to get cleaned. Could not recommend more!!”

4.9 Superb163 Reviews

“This store is amazing and the customer service is great. This store carries a huge amount of charms and I was looking for a pelican and not only did they have one but the store clerk helped me dig through all of her Beach charms to see if they had one. I totally appreciated the great customer service and I will definitely be back.”

4.8 Superb48 Reviews

“227 Broad St location closed at 11:15am.
All lights on in store. No note saying why they are closed when hours posted online say they are open. What irks me the most is I paid for parking!

UPDATE: Thank you for the pro-customer response! I’m a repeat customer and I was frustrated! I’ve updated the rating because I’ve always had a good experience!”

4.9 Superb37 Reviews

“We had an excellent experience working with Lynne and Alissa on buying a diamond and designing an engagement ring as well as getting an heirloom wedding band resized.

We first walked into the shop Mother's Day weekend, and despite all the traffic, Lynne made time to help us try on a few rings and set up an appointment for later.

I'm not a big jewelry person, and I really appreciate the effort Lynne and Alissa went to ordering different sizes and colors of diamonds to try, as well as the guidance we got on ring design. They are very responsive and we were notified immediately via text and email when something came in to see or when our CAD design was delivered.

Over the month or so that we worked with them, we always felt prioritized and warmly welcomed. I'm actually a little sad to have received our rings because it's been lovely getting to know them and hanging out while we've been in the design process.

Admittedly, we didn't really shop around because we were so pleased with the service we received and we've stayed well within our budget, but I've been on various jewelry/engagement ring forums during this time and I feel that their pricing was quite competitive and they were very transparent about cost through the process (though Lynne did clarify first if I wanted to talk about price and how we as a couple wanted to proceed, which I also appreciated).”

4.7 Superb76 Reviews

“I’ve been going to see Kathy and Paul since before I can remember, with my family. 2023 was the first year I got to work with them myself, designing wedding bands for my wife and I. Kathy was amazing, we worked on the overall design for a while before working on exactly which stones we wanted.
Kathy was willing to go above and beyond to make our rings exactly as we imagined them; so we got what we wanted (and one of a kind rings out of it too!)
I can’t recommend them enough after going to see Kathy for 30 years and being able to work so closely with her and her team.”

4.7 Superb40 Reviews

“Great place! I never sold jewelry or coins and had no Idea of value, the staff was extremely friendly and knowledgeable as they helped me and also explained the difference in gold. Their price was extremely fair when they purchased the jewelry. I will be back with my coins, i would recommend them to anyone
Thank you Wisconsin precious metals”

4.6 Superb47 Reviews

“We purchased this fantastic piece of art last year. We love it. It's hand painted, canvas wrap. We just stopped by your store looking for another piece of black and white art to match the one we already have, which unfortunately we didn't find. If you bring in more black ad white art that is 16×20 (or 17×21 the actual size) please leave a comment and we'll come in and purchase. Keep up the great work! Cheers!”

5 Superb10 Reviews

“Such a beautiful store with amazing finds and affordable prices. Found an awesome mulicolored cross here and I love it. Will definitely be back next time I’m in town.”

4.6 Superb40 Reviews

“I was in town for work and decided to randomly stop by this vintage shop. And I’m glad I did! If you’re into vinyl records, you HAVE to stop by. There are a couple of thousand records throughout the store (and thousands more in storage from what I was told). All from 1990 and before, all original, and well taken care of. They also have plenty of vintage signs, kitchen wares, Knick knacks and more. The couple who own the shop are very warm and friendly. And it’s connected to a bowling alley?! Next time I’m in town, I’ll definitely be stopping by to look through all they have and do some bowling!”

4.5 Superb14 Reviews

“This place is great! They have a lot of cute stuff. Necklaces, earrings, purses, gloves, etc.... Great prices too! I always bring out-of-town guests here and they love it!”

3.5 Good26 Reviews

“Honestly,I'm obsessed with this place! You can score the ultimate vacation look here with their gorgeous resort wear and stunning Italian Sterling Silver jewelry. Plus,their deals are unmatched-where else can you find the cutest tank tops for $3.99 or comfy and stylish sweatpants for just $6.99 !?
This place is packed with cool mugs,an amazing magnet selection and endless treasure hunting. Definitely make Christines your stop!👍😘”

4 Good96 Reviews