8AM - 4:30PM
2045 Atwood Ave Ste 105, Madison
Auto Insurance
8:30AM - 5PM
2009 W Beltline Hwy Ste 100, Madison
Auto Insurance
“I have worked with a lot of agents over the years and this is the only insurance agency I would leave a review for. These agents really do care about their clients. You can’t ask for a better Agency than these guys and gals.”
“Very responsive and helpful! Always get a response same day and personalized service from Aaron’s team. Also appreciate their willingness to match my communication preferences (e.g. text) when I am busy and on the go.”
“I’ve been part of American Family for 20+ years, when I heard of my agents retirement announcement, I was questioning at that point if her replacement would be as good on a professional level. Once Dan took over with his own agency, my thoughts and concerns were immediately addressed as Dan is a great guy, very approachable, knowledgeable, and has a passion for the industry as well as he has educated his staff on that same mission, vision, and they have the same values
Anytime I have had a question in regards to my policies or incidents. It has been addressed timely and professionally so I am very pleased to have Dan and his staff continue to be my preferred insurance choice.”
8AM - 4PM
5530 Eastpark Blvd, Madison
Auto Insurance
“Josh has been our insurance agent for many years. He always takes the time to work with us to explain our options for coverage. His staff is top notch—very friendly, experienced and helpful. I highly recommend Josh and his agency for all your insurance needs.”
“I've had overwhelmingly positive experiences with Mardsen State Farm over the past decade. Everyone there is competent, clear in communication, compassionate, and friendly. I've had to file several claims for auto and home, and they have always been amazing, from start to finish.”
9AM - 4PM
3821 Nakoma Rd, Madison
Auto Insurance
“Kailey was super helpful in getting me the information I needed! I reached out to this group because I was confused on which branch of American Family I needed to work with. I cold-emailed and Kailey responded -- she was super friendly and gave great customer service, pulling the number I needed to call even though it wasn't associated with this branch. Awesome customer service!!”
9AM - 5PM
3312 Packers Ave, Madison
Auto Insurance
“Jennifer and Gail always take care of us. They are very responsive whenever we have questions about our policies, coverage, etc. I appreciate their commitment to service, their insight, and their guidance.”
1 - 5PM 8:30AM - 12PM
2310 Crossroads Dr # 1600, Madison
Auto Insurance
“For the past ten plus years I have used the Melissa Bizeau State Farm agency for my insurance needs. Melissa and her staff have always been very helpful and quick to respond to any questions I have regarding my insurance policies. (Life, home and auto.)
This is a professional and trustworthy insurance agency. I highly recommend Melissa Bizeau State Farm!”
8:30AM - 5PM
821 E Washington Ave #110, Madison
Auto Insurance
“Matty has been our agent since our previous agent retired several years ago. We have been very pleased with the service ever since he and the Scher agency took over our policies. He is extremely knowledgeable, friendly and very helpful. Our calls are returned promptly and he explains complex language so that you understand what the policy says and intends. He reaches out before you see an increase letter to talk about why the change is coming and if available, discusses the options for mitigating the price increase while still keeping the coverage needed and wanted. We are so pleased to hear that he has taken over the agency. We know that we will be in excellent hands going into the future.”
8:30AM - 5PM
525 Junction Rd Suite 6500, Madison
Auto Insurance
“Mike listened well, found solutions to what I needed, and has provided consistent and timely responses to my follow-up questions and ongoing needs. Top shelf service.”
“Emily was very helpful and easy to talk to. She made sure I understood everything and found affordable pricing that worked for me. I’m very satisfied with her service.”
“I recently had my garage door opener repaired by this company and I was very impressed with the service. The technician who came to my home was very knowledgeable and efficient and was able to diagnose and fix the problem quickly. The service was affordable and of high quality. I would definitely recommend this company to anyone in need of garage door repairs.”
“Jim & Kathy ALWAYS deliver reputable insurance services exactly how I hope. There is never a hassle. Insurance can be scary, but these folks give personable service. Respect yourself by contacting real, caring humans like Jim & Kathy!”
9AM - 5PM
425 Grand Canyon Dr, Madison
Auto Insurance
“I can’t say enough how pleased I am with my agent here. Luke is so responsive to all of my requests. Policy changes are a breeze. Had hail damage to my car earlier this year and the claim process was way easier than I expected. If I could give them more than five stars I would!”
“Very timely responses to email and phone calls. Matty and every staff members are very friendly and knowledgeable. They take every customer concern/issues very seriously and address sincerely. Overall Excellent service. I would definitely recommend D Webster-Scher agency to all your insurance needs in WI. Thank You Prashant”
“Insurance can be complicated. It is great to talk to a real person that can explain options. I was ready to leave AllState because I couldn't get answers through the corporate website or calling the corporate 800 number. Finding a local agent that took the time to explain options and details, as well as ways to save on my insurance, saved me from having to change insurance companies.”
9AM - 6PM
668 N High Point Rd, Madison
Auto Insurance
“Clinton Ndlovu was great (6 stars), he answered all my questions, explained all my options and was very polite. Great customer service, didn't rush me or pressure me and because of his dedication I will definitely recommend him.”
“We just transferred our insurance to Rural Mutual, after 50 years with another company. We were told by our agent that we would need to pay a $65 annual member fee. When we went online to pay for this fee it showed payment amount due as $70. We called Customer Service and were told that the member fee was $65 but they also add a $5.00 donation on the amount that is due. We were told we could edit this amount to $65, which we did. We feel that this is deceptive. If the company is looking at donations beyond the member fee it should be noted as such on the online payment site. This is definitely a red flag for us. We never had this kind of deception with State Farm. I would ask that Rural Mutual be more honest and upfront on the added $5.00 donation fee on their online payment site, and list it as such.”
“I am grateful that American Family Insurance insures my home against floods and fires, as other insurance companies are declining these coverages.
However, in December they sent me their bill, saying that if I pay the full amount of 1,671.69, I will save $81.71. This discount is only 4.88%. I think loyal customers who pay in full every year, given the increasing tariffs, should get a better discount, like 20% off. Never had any claims still my rates keep going up.
Tried car insurance with American Family Insurance, and despite being their customer for many years, the rates they offered were astronomical.”
“Linda at Prairie land Insurance was great to work with and got me a good deal after the company we had been with for over 10 years was gouging us on rates. Would recommend.”