Play It Again Sports Madison is a locally owned sporting goods and fitness store that specializes in buying and selling quality used gear. Customers can trade in their equipment for cash or discounts on new items. The store offers a wide range of competitively priced new and used equipment for various sports, including hockey, lacrosse, baseball, cycling, and more. The staff is known for their exceptional customer service, providing knowledgeable assistance and quick responses. Many customers have praised the team for helping them find the right gear, such as golf clubs and barbells, and for services like skate sharpening and equipment tuning. Overall, it is a great place to shop for sports and fitness needs while supporting local business.
There are no other options for used sporting goods, so by default it's the best one in Madison. 😅 The prices are inflated but I found a few things for my home gym without any trouble. The staff were nice.
September 2025
Big thanks to Derrick! His knowledge and guidance helped me (a noob) pick some great golf clubs at a great price! 10/10 customer service!
August 2025
Great service. AJ was extremely helpful. Highly recommend.
