Old-Fashioned Food in Mayville, Wisconsin, is a fantastic cheese store known for its wide selection and friendly staff. Customers enjoy exploring the cheese cellar, which offers many different cheeses, including unique and delicious cheese curds that are considered the best around. The store takes the time to package small servings, allowing visitors to try a variety of flavors. Many find it to be their favorite place to get cheese, with great assortments of cheese ends and pieces to sample new tastes. Whether visiting for the first time or a regular, it’s a must-see for any cheese lover looking for high-quality cheeses and a welcoming atmosphere.
Awesome store located in the lower section of building stop in
May 2025
When I was on the road. When ever I was passing through. I would always stop to purchase the best cheese in Wisconsin. The 12 year old cheddar is absolutely delicious on an Angus burger.
October 2024
Great selection of the finest cheese. Wine selection... wow.. definitely recommend
