Thrift Stores near New Berlin, WI

28 locations found near New Berlin

“I would have given a 4, however I went for children cloths and sadly the kids cloths are all mixed in boys and girls were all together. I love being able to get a boys top and not look at it and say what is this doing in here.
Over all it was clean easy in and out just need some work on kids area”

3.5 Good101 Reviews

“Very cool place for all sorts of collectibles! We really enjoyed getting to look around at everything and bought a few figures! I liked that they even had a video game section with multiple consoles!”

4.6 Superb124 Reviews

“This is a true Bargain store. Prices on everything is low and fair. The sales are awesome. Where can you get a bag full of treasures for $10?! Stop in some time and spend time looking at everything. You won’t leave empty handed!”

4.8 Superb58 Reviews

“Super cute thrift store with an amazing variety of items! Honestly something for everyone. The store is staged beautifully, smells nice and the prices are unbelievable. Violet runs the shop and she’s incredibly sweet and helpful. Highly recommend stopping in!”

4.7 Superb31 Reviews

“Such a cute store with friendly staff. Nice vignettes of seasonal merch. Ever-changing inventory but a wide selection of sizes and styles. Even if you're not looking for something specific and just browsing, you'll find something!”

4.6 Superb48 Reviews

“This is my favorite spot in the neighborhood! I’ve found some of my favorite shoes here for 3 DOLLARS. And the ladies and the atmosphere are just lovely. ❤️??”

4.9 Superb30 Reviews

“great store , always find something there at a great price !! and today they had a pop up food bank! ( Tuesday and Friday 1:00) they gave out alot of great food including frozen pizzas thank you Super Thrift you all are a true blessing !!”

4.4 Superb56 Reviews

“We love this community staple!! The prices are incredible and we love their mission. Stop supporting Goodwill immediately & donate here! The volunteers are so kind and helpful & the store is meticulously organized, having everything you could need at an affordable price with hidden vintage gems you won’t find anywhere else. Highly suggest bringing cash to make it easy on them or you can pay by card $5 minimum (which sometimes is hard to hit with their sales ?)”

4.6 Superb45 Reviews

“Recently discovered this resale shop and I'm so happy i did. We went when they had the red tag bag sale. Meaning that all red tag items you can fit into the bag will only cost $1. We scored some amazing deals and the shoes were no more than $6. What a great store will be returning.”

4.8 Superb38 Reviews

“One of the best goodwill stores in the country. Quality fitting rooms, restrooms, organized shopping, even some color-coordinated displays of products. Employees are friendly and helpful. A good balance of different products here”

4.3 Superb117 Reviews

“This store is amazing! They have a huge variety of things the staff is friendly the store is clean Natalie made sure to look out for me. Im so mad the store in dallas is not like this because thats were i live! Thank you all keep up the good work”

4.2 Good220 Reviews

“Yesterday was my first time going to this store and I was so impressed. The lady who runs it was so sweet. She has everything priced so well. I got a bunch of kids books that were about 15 cents each, a nice little jacket and boots, and other random items. Some things were 5 cents. All the clothes and shoes were free with a certain limit per week. How wonderful!”

4.5 Superb9 Reviews

“Great place but recently prices have really went up was a weekly customer but stopped going could not afford much as to other thrift shops but asst mgr lady is amazing so help full will give another chance w hope things have adjusted.”

4.2 Good63 Reviews

“I googled the times for the thrift store and they were wrong. The thrift store closed at 2 PM today Wednesday. I only had a few minutes to shop. There was not a lot of merchandise they need donations. Today is March 26, 2025. I’ve always enjoyed the deals here!”

4.4 Superb18 Reviews

“Awesome staff especially Lisa she is awesome and very helpful! Nice resource if your living arrangements change! Great organization!!! Very helpful and resources available especially if you're willing to help and better yourself!”

4.1 Good51 Reviews

“While this place doesn't take in donations, it appears they get there stock from other sources. The place is nicely organized and clean. It does offer a whole lot of different types of stuff. Electronics, clothes, TVs, furniture, household supplies, etc.”

4 Good80 Reviews

“Very clean and orderly. Didn't find much that I wanted but it was so easy to look. Will try back another day now thhat I've noticed what a pleasant place this is to visit.”

4 Good186 Reviews

“Great place to buy and get second hand furniture.
Just be ready for the people that come here. Had someone hit my parked car, they had no insurance and were aggressively pressuring us not to call the police. Employees were just watching on, felt unsafe to go here since then.”

3.9 Good121 Reviews

“Cute little shop, very friendly volunteers. I found price reasonable and the day I went, everything was 50% off! They were giving out stuffies with a $10 purchase. I only spent $8 and the still gave me one! A medium size squish melon unicorn colors that my 3 yr old granddaughter is going to LOVE? ALSO- in the cutest little town. I mean ADORABLE!”

3.6 Good57 Reviews

“Very attentive and helpful staff! Had some awesome finds, one of the cleanest goodwills I’ve ever been to! They had a strickly Brewer’s section which I thought was cool, would def recommend making the same type of section for the Bucks & Packers stuff! Overall great experience though!”

3.7 Good121 Reviews

“This Goodwill Store still offers used Blu Rays. So they’re not going the route of other greedy Goodwill Store’s that send all their Blu Ray discs to their e-commerce website. ?”

3.7 Good131 Reviews

“I've been shopping here weekly for about a year. The prices are always reasonable, selection is very good & the checkout never takes too long. There is always something interesting and unique to find here!”

3.7 Good136 Reviews

“I really like this Salvation Army store.. it is well kept up, good layout, the people who work there are friendly, and appreciate my humor..ha..
>just keep the prices low so you can keep moving the products out on the quick.. low $ means we buy more!..ha. 4.5 Stars!~ Sven”

3.1 Average16 Reviews

“I love the salvation army and what it still does to help the community one of the best and honest still out there. The store was very clean and had good customer service as well. Nice furniture for cheap prices.”

3.3 Good23 Reviews

“I think this store has a wide variety of items to choose from. Everything is reasonably priced. It’s a resale shop so some items are in better condition than others. People who complain about the quality are free to shop elsewhere. I love shopping here ?”

3.5 Good107 Reviews

“This dollar tree has all the latest viral stuff, great staff, and a great assortment of unusual cleaning supplies, like apple scented fabuloso, which is heavenly!”

3.4 Good121 Reviews

“Great prices with a color special like Goodwill used to have. 30% of the special color tag on all items and another color tag fo 99¢ clothing prices. Way better than Goodwill is now.”

3.5 Good137 Reviews

“I like going thrifting at Goodwill because all the clothes and blankets and bedsheets are clean and folded or on hangers. They’re organized sometimes by color sometimes by size, and it makes shopping very helpful. They have a lot of kitchen items and picture frames and school supplies. Plus there’s always a stock person in the aisle who is happy to help you find something. Thank you for the service.”

3.4 Good132 Reviews