Goodwill Store & Donation Center is open and accepting donations through contact-less methods at the donation vestibule. Donors are asked to box or bag their items, and a donation receipt is available upon request. The store offers a variety of merchandise, including kitchen items such as pots, pans, dinnerware, cups, glasses, and cutlery, as well as clothes and shoes. Customers have found good deals and treasures, like brand-name handbags and summer tops, especially with the store’s new point system that allows some items to be free. However, some shoppers feel prices are rising and now resemble Walmart, making used clothes less worthwhile. The store is praised as the best thrift store in Milwaukee, with a well-organized layout and friendly staff. Occasionally, shoppers find amazing bargains, like clothing and accessories at a fraction of retail prices. Overall, it’s a place to find unique items and enjoy a safe, organized shopping experience.
Livy from Brooklyn was a great staff member and very knowledgeable. She’s dope if you go there ask for her assistance!
March 2026
Mystery bags were not according to size as indicated, 2nd time , 2 different stores,, also noticed garments are put in to color not size. Good will on S.43 was a disappointment 😞
March 2026
Very attentive and helpful staff! Had some awesome finds, one of the cleanest goodwills I’ve ever been to! They had a strickly Brewer’s section which I thought was cool, would def recommend making the same type of section for the Bucks & Packers stuff! Overall great experience though!
