The Historic Plains Hotel is a unique and charming establishment located in the heart of downtown. With a rich history, it is almost like a museum, showcasing beautiful stained glass and historical memorabilia. Guests appreciate the convenient location, close to restaurants, bars, and various activities. The hotel's service is noted as very good, with friendly staff providing a smooth experience from check-in to check-out. While the hotel exudes charm, many reviews point out that the rooms are in need of renovations. Some guests describe the accommodations as quirky but warn that the rooms can feel old and tired, with issues such as worn carpets, dirty windows, and street noise. The reservation system has also been described as messy. Despite these drawbacks, many visitors enjoy the spaciousness of the rooms and the comfort of the beds. Overall, The Historic Plains Hotel offers a glimpse into the past and is recommended for those who appreciate history and character over modern luxury. It is a place to experience a piece of local heritage, though it may not meet the expectations of guests looking for a polished, contemporary stay.
From the moment of check-in, until checkout we were treated with hospitality. Loved everything about the stay. The bar downstairs is great.
March 2026
I loved staying here! Yes, it is the historic hotel and yes, you can definitely tell but beautifully designed and best location in Cheyenne. Wigwam bar was Open and the lady at the bar was absolutely fantastic. We got to try some awesome Jell-O shots that she made herself. We next time We’re in Cheyenne we will be... read full comment
October 2025
I absolutely highly recommend this BEAUTIFUL hotel. It is haunted but don't worry. The ghosts there are harmless. 😜 So c'mon to The Historic Plains Hotel!!!!
