Thrift Stores near Cotati, CA

30 locations found near Cotati

“This little store is exceptional. Always worth stopping in for a little trade on some odd little goodies. The guy running the place is a delight, not pushy, a pleasure to bargain with, and will always assure you whatever thing you picked is the best thing. The amazing part is that this guy knows exactly what he has and exactly where it is. You probably won’t find what you’re looking for but guaranteed you’ll find three or more things you weren’t.”

4.7 Superb54 Reviews

“It's a crafters dream bargain spot. Fabric, yarn, thread, crayons, paper, you name it they probably have it at some point. Almost all 2nd hand stuff at reasonable prices. Love to browse it when I'm in the area.”

4.5 Superb158 Reviews

“One of the best thrift shops in Sonoma County. I always find some random unique goodie here that I love. It seems like it's one of the few thrift stores that still has low prices that you would expect at a thrift store. Other places like the Goodwill have risen over the years, and has become less appealing. But these types of thrift stores still exist and I <3 Pick of the Litter as one of them. I have found things for my dog, clothes, gifts, vases, and random things like yoga balls. It's also open on Sundays (some that are religious thrift shops are closed). The ladies at the front are helpful, and there's always parking up front.

NEW pics as of Jan 2026 at their new location on Industrial Dr (the old Joann’s building!)”

4.4 Superb173 Reviews

“Dave has so many amazing , wonderful items in his store! From antiques to tools, from books to electronics, from rare records to cool computer games.
You'll want you visit frequently as the store's stock is constantly being added to. Prices are reasonable to bargain.
While you are in the area, stop by next door to check out their amazing store! Shoes, garden supplies, clothes, bedding, housewares, collectibles not to mention their fantastic Halloween and Christmas holiday displays and sales! 10 out of 10!”

4.8 Superb41 Reviews

“Everyone in the store were so polite and homey. I found lots of great things at great prices, and next door on weekends they have a cat lounge! They're supporting a good cause and they're doing it the right way. 100% would recommend.”

4.5 Superb64 Reviews

“One of the best thrift stores in Petaluma !! Totally had an amazing & fun treasure-hunt experience at this place. Very reasonably priced. I got my loot & thrill :)

Friendly & kind staff person & store owner too it seems.”

4.3 Superb125 Reviews

“Great service and the owners are so kind and helpful. I have found a fave pair of boots, a few dresses that were in great shape and fit perfectly! They have a wide selection of items, something for everyone. I even picked up some puzzles and toys for my classroom. Definitely one of my fave thrift stores in the north bay.”

4.5 Superb50 Reviews

“Great service, friendly staff, and they have a wide variety of products. I find it offensive that someone would be offended at something that was sold in another era, when people were not offended of making fun of each other. If you don't like something don't buy it. Those type of items are collectible by the way, and depict a historical time that we should not forget, and learn from.”

4.3 Superb70 Reviews

“We recently donated several pieces of furniture. We were delighted with all aspects of the process. Everyone involved was communicative, polite, and helpful. We were very appreciative of the pick up service. Thank you for the ability to give this furniture a second life.”

4.3 Superb56 Reviews

“I absolutely love this secondhand store. It feels like the community serving the community. My husband and I usually give to another Thrift Shop but recently we’ve been drawn to Heavenly Treasures. We’ve donated so much stuff and it’s brought us so much joy to help the church and to serve others in our giving.”

4.5 Superb23 Reviews

“Went to this super awesome little shop a few days ago it’s so cool in there and has some good finds! Very nice and helpful owner! Gave me directions to another store with more items I was in search for!”

4.8 Superb14 Reviews

“Best consignment store in Sebastopol! I have bought and sold clothes here over the years. The owner is very dedicated to her business, kind and helpful. The prices are good, the store is clean and organized. Lots of fun and unique clothes and goods to choose from!”

4.1 Good45 Reviews

“Good selection of more sophisticated clothing but not necessarily a wide selection. Everything is very high quality and well taken care of. Clean, bright, and welcoming store, on the small side. Staff are very kind and welcoming. Clothing and items are appropriately priced and a good deal. I will definitely be returning!”

4.1 Good28 Reviews

“I have always discovered some great finds when visiting this fun thrift store/non-profit. The staff are super friendly , the merchandise well organized and everything is priced fairly.”

3.9 Good87 Reviews

“Everyone has to realize the women working here- are volunteering their time and energy to be there. They are not getting paid. The proceed go to scholarship funds. The store has some cute items, but just like any thrift store, you'll have to browse for everything. It smells a like old dusty times & clothes because (gasp!) they are! Everything has been donated. The workers aren't going to go and wash the clothes again. So let's please show these hardworking volunteers some grace. The volunteers are all very sweet and cute. They are friendly and try their best to help. The store has been reorganized and separated to clothing, household goods, etc. Whenever I'm in town, I like to browse and usually find something good.”

3.9 Good36 Reviews

“I really like this store. It's large and well organized. The staff especially the longer term employees and the managers are friendly and very fair. Always enjoy searching for unique items here.”

3.8 Good23 Reviews

“First time here. Lots to look at. Got three pairs of jeans at a wine bottle holder for about $15! Friendly workers. Need at least a half hour to an hour to look around at everything.”

3.8 Good81 Reviews

“St Vincent De Paul Truly do great things in this community they really help you if you truly in dire need of some assistance to all the people who work there to make things happen and help the community shout out to you guys with more people like you guys the world is a better place shopping here not only gets you great prices and deals on things you need for your home and personal things but all of that money goes right back into helping the people who need help in the community im telling you that personally because i did my research and they helped me when i truly needed it thank you St Vincent De Paul for all that you guys do ❤️”

3.8 Good113 Reviews

“I found this cafe because I work in the area and am SO HAPPY i did! It’s a great spot to stop in the morning and grab a quick bite and drink. The staff is always so polite and professional, you get greeted by almost everyone, and the food’s delicious. The Lemon Scone is one of the best i’ve ever had. Love the cause, love the place, and couldn’t recommend more!”

3.6 Good58 Reviews

“Prices are great and they always have a great selection of stuff. I've bought several pieces of really nice furniture. Plus the folks at check out were amazing.”

3.5 Good41 Reviews

“Crossing the Jordan helped my neighbor. She had a plumbing problem that flooded her home. I went to this store and purchased a big bag of towels at a very reasonable price. They saved the day!After the Tubbs fire of 2017, this store helped many people to get their household back to a functional state. The community won’t forget this generosity.”

3.5 Good112 Reviews

“I want to five a shout out to whoever the person was that packaged the very heavy, old and expensive sculpture that I bought on the online auction from this location. Whoever did it really cared. Unfortunately this isn't the norm nowadays on the shop Goodwill auction site in general. I have ordered so many items and paid thousands in the past few weeks alone but I will be stopping with the majority of the locations because the photography, dishonesty and/or packing is so bad.
But whoever did the packing on this item: you're a good person and professional at your job. Thank you.”

3.4 Good82 Reviews

“Great thrift store that is well organized. I find cute things here often. Plus not far down the road is a goodwill I also have good luck with. The staff are always friendly here as well. A+”

3.4 Good86 Reviews

“Redwood Mission thrift shop has been my favorite for many years, partly because they saved my friend's life after he stumbled into their mission and join their program. Also, they offer store credit if you buy clothes take them home and they don't fit, which hardly any other thrift shops offer. They also have the largest offering of furniture of any thrift shop in Santa Rosa. Their prices are reasonable and every week they offer 50% off certain tag colors. They also accept almost everything I take there for donation. Some of the other thrift shops in town have gotten very picky.”

3.5 Good175 Reviews

“We were in the area and came here. There's plenty of parking. It's very organized and clean. I noticed they had a lot of clothes all very clean. They had a great book section. Most book were pretty new and these are books you can find at target within the last year. They were priced very reasonable. Hardcover $2 and paper backs $1. The lady who rang us up was very pleasant. Overall we had a good experience.”

3.2 Average75 Reviews

“I’m in town visiting for a few months. I like to check out the local Goodwill. This one’s not bad, I would like to see it merchandised a bit better. It’s unfortunate that there are no dressing rooms and no refunds. I found a few items here and I’m sure I’ll be back again.”

3.1 Average64 Reviews

“1 Of The Best Good-Will Locations (Petaluma, Calif. 94952) In The Sonoma County Red-Wood Empire Having A Gigantic Collection Of The Really Awesome Donated Clothing, Literature, Artistry, Furniture, Sporting And Electronics That Are Priced Economically Not To Mention 100% Five Gold Star Cordial Faculty Members (Cashiers To Stockers To Aceptors) In The Definitely Laid-Back Atmosphere By The Elegant And Orderly To Be Well-Lite, Completely Ventilated Along With Full Aisle Room, Easy Admission Drop-Off Contribute Area, Lots Of The Parking Spaces Being A 9 A.M. To 8 P.M. Continual Operation By The A1 First-Class Quality!!!”

3 Average59 Reviews

“I had an excellent experience with Michelle today. She was very patient, kind, and took the time to explain everything clearly. She provided me with the best options available, always making sure they worked in my favor. Her professionalism and friendly attitude made the whole process easy to understand and stress-free. I truly appreciate her support and the excellent service she gave me.”

3 Average98 Reviews

“I love the vintage vibe at Plato's Closet Santa Rosa. Every visit feels like a treasure hunt for unique, affordable pieces that are both cozy and eclectic. The selection is always fresh and the prices are perfect for anyone looking for a great thrift store near me. Friendly staff, clean shelves, and a fun atmosphere – highly recommend.”

3 Average196 Reviews

“Well it not the biggest store they have. it as ladies clothes children's clothes a little bit of men's clothes not a lot jackets pants woman they have a lot more clothing and lingerie some electronics housewares and knick knacks baby clothes some kids stuff toys it just as a little bit of everything . Prices are okay it's better than buying new at more than half the cost Nice cashiers I always seem to stop every week and see what they have”

2.5 Average70 Reviews