Plato's Closet Santa Rosa is a popular secondhand clothing store that recently underwent a grand reopening. The store is known for its organized, trendy selection and the ability to try on items in the dressing rooms, which sets it apart from traditional thrift stores. However, the experience of selling clothes to Plato's Closet has been mixed. While the staff is generally friendly and professional, some customers have reported feeling disappointed with the selection process. Many claim that the store has been overly selective, rejecting items that appear to be in good condition. The pricing at Plato's Closet is also a point of discussion, with some customers finding the prices on the higher side, especially for shoes and Lululemon items. Despite this, the store does offer occasional hidden gems, such as a vintage Coach purse for around $30. One of the main complaints about the Santa Rosa location is the parking situation, which has been described as a "mess" due to the store's recent reopening. Customers have reported getting stuck in the back parking area, and the lot itself is in need of cleaning. Overall, Plato's Closet Santa Rosa seems to provide a more curated shopping experience than a traditional thrift store, but the selling process and the store's current operational challenges have left some customers feeling frustrated. While the store remains a popular destination for secondhand fashion, shoppers and sellers may need to manage their expectations accordingly.
Amazing store I got so many good deals on Lululemon
June 2026
We love Plato’s closet for cute sundresses!
June 2026
I was nervous at first, but the staff made me feel so comfortable and welcomed. I left with a pile of amazing bargains and one‑of‑a‑kind pieces that I couldn’t find anywhere else. This thrift store really delivers affordable, unique clothing that makes shopping feel like a treasure hunt.