John Atencio's first store opened in 1976 in Fort Collins, near the Colorado State University campus where John is an honored alumni. His store on North College Avenue is a homecoming from where it all began. The Fort Collins location is one of John's premier boutiques, where people come from far and wide to see, touch and feel each unique item in celebration of their own life events. Weddings, births, anniversaries and more are each celebrated through John's engagement rings, women's wedding rings, men's wedding bands, and bracelets, pendants and watches. Customers praise the exceptional customer service at the Fort Collins store, particularly from Kristin Guerra, the store manager. Kristin is described as wonderful, personable, and extremely helpful in assisting customers with a variety of jewelry needs, from picking out the perfect rings to ensuring the sizing is perfect. The store staff is also commended for their accommodating nature, seamlessly handling returns and exchanges. Overall, John Atencio's Fort Collins location is a must-visit for those seeking exquisite, beautiful jewelry and top-notch customer service.
I had a very good experience with John Atencio when looking for a piece for my wife. They have beautiful jewelry and their customer service is the best.
January 2026
Great personal service from Kristin, Boutique Manager and top quality jewelry. Our go to place for special unique jewelery.
December 2025
Kristen is amazing. She helped me convert my old wedding ring into a beautiful new pendant necklace. I absolutely love the new piece! Kristen was attentive, professional, and knowledgeable throughout the process. I will recommend over and over again!!
