Jewelry Stores in Fort Collins, CO

25 locations found near Fort Collins

“This place is fantastic. I came in with both a budget, and idea for the ring. And my ring maker, Ms. Nikoo Monem took an hour with me to find the happy medium between the two. There was no “car salesmanship”, she knew the budget and did her darndest to make sure I came in under. She then was able to have the ring made in time for a milestone for me and my now fiancee. They took the stress away from the process. I can’t thank you guys enough. I am writing this about a week out from my wedding, and you guys helped me make it special. Thank you so very much!”

5 Superb148 Reviews

“Absolutely a wonderful team to work with! I loved their creative ideas and enthusiasm for our special celebration. They took something rarely worn and make it into something new and extremely special! Thank you.”

5 Superb126 Reviews

“Sather’s is the Go-to for all my fine jewelry desires. Everyone is incredibly helpful and friendly, I always feel seen and respected. The selection and quality of jewelry is unmatched. The estate collection is extensive, yet carefully selected. By far my favorite place to shop. 10/10!”

4.8 Superb221 Reviews

“Maddie was amazing!!! Loved the store, so many cute things and her customer service skills were exceptional! She was incredibly sweet. They had good deals on their sale rack too which I always love. Such a great experience!”

5 Superb69 Reviews

“***June 28,2026***
Another amazing experience with Kristin at John Atencio in Fort Collins. I am trying to add to our Decision wedding set that we bought there years ago and Kristin has been great to work with. This isn’t easy when you are trying to make something they don’t already offer and she has been so patient with me. I can’t wait to see the end result!

***
My husband and I went into the John Atencio in Ft. Collins and Kristin was amazing! She showed us several pieces I wanted to see and even took my personal pieces to clean while we were there! I then came back several more times to try and make a decision which each time Kristin was very patient and helpful!”

4.9 Superb77 Reviews

“My experience with Millennium tattoos was incredible. I couldn’t say enough about Heidi, not only is she an amazing tattoo artist but she’s a really really great person. I go my first tattoo here and it healed very quickly and the price was super reasonable. I went back for a small touch up and scheduling was so easy, she fit me in really quick. I’m so happy with how the tattoo turned out and how well it healed! I’m definitely coming back here for my next one! Love you guys! ❤”

4.8 Superb113 Reviews

“I went in to get a piece sent for repairs, and Kayla, Meghan, Ashley, and one other female employee who’s name I did not get, were so so soo helpful. I felt like such an inconvenience having them switch jewelry I changed my mind about which they JUST placed. It was temporary jewelry while I wait for the repairs to come back and I was so iffy about the piece I chose and they really wanted me to be comfortable with the piece, that they swapped it out within 15 minutes of closing. Such great people, honestly I felt terrible asking for it and they were so willing to switch it out. I’m not saying to ask for a piece done while they’re about to close, but I’m so appreciative for them to be so so willing to help, it truly shows the great people who work here.”

4.7 Superb268 Reviews

“The gentleman that looked at my jewelry and some coins impressed me so much. He was very knowledgeable and gave a very wonderful price on the items I brought in. I totally recommend going there!”

4.7 Superb151 Reviews

“One of my favorite shops in fort collins since my time at CSU from 2013-2016. Ten years later I still have to stop here to browse every time I make it up to visit the area! Can be pricey but lots of locally made items, and unique gifts you won't find anywhere else.”

4.7 Superb138 Reviews

“Big store with lots of lovely souvenirs from art, jewellery to clothing’s you can even find some Xmas ornaments in here. It’s whole working in here were polite and nice. You can pay with card or cash.”

4.7 Superb84 Reviews

“I contacted Kelly by email one day earlier and he asked me to bring my ring in the next day. I did drop the ring off the next day and Kelly told me could do the modification same day. I picked up the ring later that day. I was very satisfied with his work, but especially since he was able to complete the modification same day.”

4.8 Superb48 Reviews

“HEY you made my DAY in Fort Collins. This is Fort Collins. Not a lot of hippies, but some college kids, family oriented town. Yes, this is square but very friendly town. Over 20 boutiques in one small town. I really love the variety of clothes & accessories. I do regret that I ain't have anything from here. If I didn't see it myself, I wouldn't believe this shop exist in Fort Collins. But hey, if you are in Fort Collins, stop by there. You could spend $ 100 - 150, you would get high quality chic stuffs. It is hard to get this reasonable prices within Colorado. Locally owned. This town is always privileged. Boot your positive vibe with the staff or even she is the owner I am not sure. Well, you know what, I gonna buy something next time, for sure. The vintage vibe Cardigans I am craving in there.”

4.9 Superb42 Reviews

“Love their earrings. They are colorful and very light. Large selection of shapes and sizes..Best part for me..order directly from the shop with free shipping.”

4.9 Superb31 Reviews

“I took two pieces of vintage jewelry here to be restored. I was very nervous, but the jewelers were communicative, professional, and respectful of my specific wishes. I am so grateful to have the pieces returned and exactly how I dreamed. Restored and well-groomed. I highly recommend Santa Fe Craftaman for any jewelry restoration.”

4.7 Superb48 Reviews

“Loved talking with Taylor!! She helped me last year and I bought a sweater (a favorite ?❤️) . This time I found beautiful earrings and my husband loved talking to her!! I need to go back tomorrow and get 2 t- shirts for my high school granddaughter! Great store and friendly ?”

4.9 Superb36 Reviews

“Emma helped me pick out my engagement ring. She was so patient and really supported me in getting exactly what I wanted, as well as helping me learn what options there were. Highly recommend.”

4.6 Superb82 Reviews

“What an absolutely wonderful experience I had with Deb helping me with a new wedding band after my original one was too small and beyond repair. I felt totally taken care of. I have total trust not only in her artistic abilities but her integrity. My finished ring was more beautiful than anticipated as she went to extra steps to add more designs.”

5 Superb18 Reviews

“Greg was amazing. After 22 years of marriage, my wife's diamond popped off and was lost. She was devastated. After shopping around we decided on Dawson's. He had nicer diamonds for the same price and was a better value than the competition. Sathers tried telling my wife she needed to completely ditch the old ring, since it wouldn't hold up and buy a new one. Greg inspected it and said it wasn't necessary, saving us a ton. There was a mix-up with our phone number, so he even drove to our house to make sure we didn't have to wait longer. Couldn't be happier with Greg and highly recommended his services. He doesn't have some fancy showroom, so if that's what you're looking for, you may be a little disappointed. However, I'd rather go somewhere that doesn't spend money on that and get a better value.”

4.7 Superb35 Reviews

“Wow, my experience in this store was incredible! Brikiah is a stylist extraordinaire! I came in not knowing what I wanted and she zeroed in on some ideas, made sure I had the proper fit (I would have bought jeans 2 sizes too big), and helped my narrow down to some great options. I came out feeling good. At first glance I thought their prices were expensive, but you get what you pay for. I love these pieces and will wear them for years. This will be my new go to shop for clothing!”

4.6 Superb42 Reviews

“Came in shortly before close, apologized and said I would be quick, but I found the store associates to be very kind and helpful, made my experience today all the better. Left with more than I expected to, and I’ll definitely be back. Thank you Haley!”

4.5 Superb135 Reviews

“Supremely kind and helpful shop. A slightly smaller selection for a slightly smaller store but it has the basics and more! A great place to build your bracelet or necklace and I was even assisted in the repair of my silver necklace and pendant.”

4.3 Superb28 Reviews

“Beautiful and fairly priced variety, PLUS Cathy was a lovely, positive, and helpful human. She was so sweet to my friends and I and she helped me find the perfect fit <3”

4.3 Superb45 Reviews

“Dave is the best around he's a honest guy and a true craftsman. I order once or twice a year being on disability I try to buy a few silver coins and a bar or two every year. Dave even put a 1/10 platinum coin he made in my order last year find someone anywhere that will do that. I'm in Philadelphia and I hope someday I can get out too Colorado too see him and visit his shop. Thanks Dave and his Secretary at the front desk she always helps you with your order if you have any questions. Very nice and polite lady Thanks again.”

4.3 Superb86 Reviews

“Cait and Dez are were amazing getting what I needed done. Zales is the place I come to to buy any jewelry. They are always so helpful and amazing. Definitely my go to. They have such beautiful jewelry and always the best sales”

4.2 Good155 Reviews