Plato's Closet is a resale store offering a broad selection of secondhand clothing at lower prices than big box stores. The store is described as clean and organized. Many customers report finding great pieces and the best prices, with some stating the selection helped them find their personal style. The clothing selection is noted as extensive, especially for men, and offers a variety of options, though it is often hit or miss and tends to favor smaller sizes. Some reviewers, however, feel the store is overpriced, comparable to a thrift store, and note that finding good items is only occasional. Criticisms include the presence of stained or damaged clothing on the racks despite store policy.
Experiences with selling items vary widely. Some sellers have a fantastic experience, describing the process as fast and efficient, with staff offering fair value and allowing them to clear out unwanted clothes quickly. Others strongly recommend against selling, stating buy prices are very low—around 20% of original retail value—and that you can make more money elsewhere. They note that while the low buy prices are stated upfront, some sellers are disappointed by the amount offered.
Staff reviews are mixed. Many customers praise the staff as incredibly friendly, fast, professional, patient, helpful, and sweet. Several reviews highlight exemplary service and commend the team's composure. Conversely, other reviewers find the staff not very nice, unhelpful, or unwelcoming, with comments that they seem to hate their jobs, leaving customers feeling tolerated rather than served. The overall customer experience at Plato's Closet depends heavily on these factors, leading to strongly positive or negative recommendations.
The thing that bugs me the most is they are so nitpicky about when you sell clothes. You are required to bring the clothes Folded nice and neat or they won’t look at them but they NEVER fold them back up as they’re putting them away.. I would appreciate The standard to be that they returned customers items neat..
June 2026
I had such an awesome time digging through the racks here and found some seriously stylish pieces at incredible prices. The store was super tidy, making it easy to spot all the best items without feeling overwhelmed. It is definitely one of my favorite places to go when I want to refresh my wardrobe without spending a fortune.
May 2026
Staff could work on being more friendly, I've only interacted with one nice employee. Clothes is ok, a little overpriced.
