The Roger Sherman Inn is a cozy and warm establishment with great ambience and festive decor. The atmosphere is often praised, with low traditional music that allows for easy conversation. Service experiences vary, with some reviews noting attentive, great, and lovely staff, while others report so-so or delayed service, especially during busy times like holidays or Saturday nights. Seating can sometimes be in cramped, busy areas like a corridor or enclosed porch, which impacts comfort. The food is generally very good, excellent, and really delicious, with excellent presentation. Highlights include a tasty hamburger, nicely prepared duck, and fresh bread. The menu selection, including prix fixe options, offers a manageable variety and can accommodate dietary restrictions. However, some items receive criticism; the lobster bisque can taste commercial, and desserts like the chocolate mousse are considered tasteless. Despite occasional disappointments, many guests express a desire to return, noting it as a wonderful place for celebrations like Christmas Eve or anniversary dinners.
Food was exceptional and seems to be a return to the quality I've always expected from the RSI.
February 2026
When I walk in it felt if I was in Europe, in France or Spain to be precise great experience and great food is worth the visit
February 2026
Exceptional stay and a perfect romantic getaway in New Canaan. Incredible restaurant, staff, and decor welcoming, elegant, and beautifully removed from everyday life.
