Jewelry Stores near Siesta Key, FL

30 locations found near Siesta Key

“was visiting from out of town and stopped in this boutique, the staff instantly were so friendly and kind and very patient with our large group of girls. 10/10 experience and will definitely be visiting again”

4.7 Superb39 Reviews

“I missed the store hours two days in a row. They must've seen me looking several times after hours because they opened the door and let me and my wife inside even though they were leaving for a family trip. I bought a wedding band made from wood from Hawaii and crushed blue opals. Couldn't be more happy and thankful.”

3.7 Good84 Reviews

“I visited to see the Siesta Key Watercolor Gemstone jewelery in person. I wanted to purchase jewelry unique to the Key as my wife has been visiting for family vacations since she was a young child with many great memories. I was hopeful this jewelry would remind her of all the good memories when she wore it. The salesperson was wonderful and even took some of the jewelry outside to get a better view in the sun. I purchased earrings, and they took great care to wrap, hand label, and place in a gift bag. My wife was very happy with the beauty and uniquely Siesta Key aspect of the gift! Thank you very much! Highly recommend!”

5 Superb173 Reviews

“Milan and Brooke helped me design an amazing custom ring for my wife's birthday. We just love it! Brooke was instrumental right from the time I walked into the store to advise, create and deliver a beautiful ring. I couldnt be more happier to have chosen Milan and will recommend anyone who is looking to order a custom ring to go there. Friendly, courteous and amazing experience!!”

5 Superb117 Reviews

“Wanted to write a huge word of appreciation to Natalie. I had been looking for something very specific and tough to find and she kept her word and helped me with my request. Her real time communications and follow through on her word are second to none. Highly recommend her for her professionalism and customer care. Thank you Natalie and thank you Mayors.”

4.9 Superb137 Reviews

“I recently visited a Pineapple Rocks shop where we bought a bracelet with sapphire and hematite inserts for our youngest daughter. I was impressed by the friendly atmosphere and the beautiful display of exhibits. It’s a very pleasant and educational place, with souvenirs and jewelry to suit every taste. Highly recommended!”

5 Superb64 Reviews

“My wife Jackie went into the store to have a battery replaced on her watch and Doron could not have been nicer. He showed her around the store to see all the beautiful jewelry. My wife returned two days later to pick up her watch and Doron said there would be no charge. We will definitely be back at Holiday Time.”

4.9 Superb88 Reviews

“The BEST PLACE to find wonderful Treasures. The Whole TEAM goes above and beyond the expectations. I would recommend this place to everyone. Thank you all for what you did for me and my Family...”

5 Superb89 Reviews

“True to their name, repairs are fast and done on site. Depending on your watch brand, batteries can be expensive but in line with other jewelers that have to send merchandise out to a 3rd party.”

4.8 Superb273 Reviews

“Thayer Jewelers offers a welcoming atmosphere. Their customer service sets them apart, making the jewelry buying experience pleasant and enjoyable. It’s a great option for those seeking quality pieces and personalized assistance.”

5 Superb64 Reviews

“What a lovely shop with the most beautiful jewels. Thank you Jojo for your time and attention in helping me select the perfect necklace and earrings. I love both!”

4.9 Superb67 Reviews

“I had to pawn a gaming system a couple months back im so glad I came to this location for my loan. These guys are human and understand hard times. They aren't looking to take your belongings if you end up needing more time to pay back. They could of they wanted to. Any other pawn shop would have. I will drive 45 min to come here anytime I need a pawn shop just because they aren't like most pawn shops out there. They are down to earth and understand people fall on hard times. They dont prey on people in their time of need. Thank you guys”

4.8 Superb161 Reviews

“Just Because isn’t only an amazing store with incredibly unique and fun inventory, but I always feel so welcome by the helpful, kind and caring sales associates. Thank you, Roberta for making my shopping experience a pure delight!”

4.9 Superb74 Reviews

“Todd and Lyra have made our gorgeous wedding rings! They are so perfect, we are so very happy with our rings!Our story is special. We live in the Netherlands. Anita had a vision about our wedding rings. We searched at the internet to find these wedding rings. We found the site handwovenbands, and we discovered that they make the exact same wedding rings as in the vision. We were amazed that this small, family run business far away in Sarasota, makes the rings from the vision.We contacted them, and Lyra helped us very kindly every step along the way.We surely think God has given Todd and Lyra a very special talent. They make such special rings. For us it is so special that they create our rings that represent the alliance between two people and God. We also like the symbolic of 2 separate individuals choose to weave their two lives together. Todd is a very gifted ringmaker with amazing jeweler skills!We will wear our wedding rings with a lot of happiness and pride.”

5 Superb50 Reviews

“The Bazaar on Apricot & Lime is one of my favorite spots for local shopping in Sarasota. It’s an indoor indie market in Sarasota with a rotating mix of local vendors and artists, so it’s easy to find creative, unique gifts—and half the fun is hearing the stories behind what people make and sell.

They also do a great job keeping things fun with events throughout the month, so there’s always something new happening.

And don’t skip Hamlet’s Eatery in the courtyard. The burger and fries are excellent, the specials are always worth checking out, and the vegetarian and vegan options are so good that even a meat-eater will be happy.

If you’re looking for unique gifts in Sarasota and want to support local makers and small businesses, The Bazaar is a great stop.”

4.8 Superb152 Reviews

“Love this small business! The owner is so sweet and welcoming! They are always eager to help and tend to your needs and thoughts about any and all of their jewelry!”

5 Superb32 Reviews

“Had a wonderful experience with Luca today. Very knowledgeable and professional. Took his time and explained things to us. My sister and I feel like we have gained a friend. Will return for any buying or selling needs in the future”

4.8 Superb94 Reviews

“We bought our lamp and rug from Max last year and fell in love with it. Not only was Max so incredibly kind and loving, but we make sure to stop by every year we are in town to say hello and see what treasures he has to offer. This year we bought 4 beautiful plates to hang in our kitchen! Can't wait to see the final look. Make sure to stop by when you are looking at all the shops in St. Armands Circle, by far the best in our opinion.”

5 Superb37 Reviews

“Cutest little gift/clothing/shoe store! Big selection of hostess/birthday gifts, I always make a point to stop at least once when down here! Thank you for your help Tonya!”

4.8 Superb105 Reviews

“Someone wrote: “Great place to find local art that makes you smile.”

That’s the case.

It is now part of our home and has survived 5000 miles unscathed.”

4.9 Superb73 Reviews

“I can not praise the A. Tifaney & Son team (Kirk Weidman & Hannah) more. Hannah was amazing at communicating expectations and the process with me. And Mr. Weisman was so kind, thorough and open with what he was doing. They both were honest and helped me with the massive estate review. I will absolutely be using them again in the future for other personal items.”

5 Superb28 Reviews

“Well she said YES! Thank you Rob for making my dreams come true. Rob designed and created my engagement ring and it was beautiful. Hands down the best experience I have had. Again, thank you.”

5 Superb43 Reviews

“My 3 friends and I, from NY, LOVED ALL jewelry!. I purchased a beautiful UNOde50 necklace. Great service from Catherine, Deb and John. I also may have picked out my husband’s “Xmas gift to me this year…haha!!”,Diane”

4.9 Superb92 Reviews

“I had never been to this jeweler before but stopped in on a Friday afternoon right before they closed with an issue with my engagement ring. They helped me right away with amazing service. I would highly recommend Carats to anyone looking for a friendly and knowledgable jeweler, and I'm happy to know I've found a place I can trust!”

4.8 Superb59 Reviews

“I purchased the most beautiful set of cufflinks as a gift for my husband at our wedding! From the moment I reached out about the item for more information, through delivery, Victoria was so kind and helpful. She shared that she had gotten married the weekend before and made sure that everything about my experience was seamless! On our wedding day, I surprised my now husband with the cuff links and he could not have loved them more. The cufflinks were in perfect condition and Victoria even went out of her way to find the box for them. He received compliments all night long and cannot wait to wear them again! Thank you for everything!! This will definitely not be our last purchase with this team!”

5 Superb40 Reviews

“Ruth was SO helpful and helped me find the perfect green amber necklace. If I lived locally I would absolutely come back again. Certainly cannot be missed if you’re visiting St. Armand’s Circle.”

4.8 Superb54 Reviews

“Went to Jared to have some engraving done on my husbands wedding band which we are gifting to our grandson for his wedding on 2/14/2026 - everyone was great especially Will Rincon - so helpful & knowledgeable since it was very emotional for me. The engraving was done ahead of schedule & when I went to pick it up Kristin helped me since Will was off that day & she was so nice & helpful - they certainly are assets to this store & the engraving was beautiful! Thank you Jared, Ruth Ahearn”

4.7 Superb92 Reviews

“Work done at the shop in front of you ! We were given the price for his service so no hidden surprises! I will be using this shop for now on . Very pleasant atmosphere, beautiful shop , friendly staff.”

4.8 Superb48 Reviews

“I left 5 jewelry items with Tom for repair. One of the items he could not get a part for. The other 4 were repaired perfectly for a total of only $80 that's $20 for each repair. Excellent job !! Highly recommended ! Great value”

5 Superb34 Reviews

“Customer service is awesome here! All the jewelry is high quality— they even have a special metal detecting machine to prove it. So happy with my new earrings I got here. Highly recommended! *(They speak Spanish here and are very friendly. Everything is high quality. I recommend this place:)”

4.8 Superb28 Reviews