Jewelry Stores in Sarasota, FL

30 locations found near Sarasota

Filters
Rating
Distance
  1. 6539 Midnight Pass Rd, Sarasota FL 34242

    5 Superb 221 reviews

    “I have trusted Silver city in Sarasota Siesta key for many years with my jewelry they are kind and honest and truly care about their customers and their prices are reasonable their integrity give me peace of mind You . I highly recommend silver city. They are the best. I recommend this place wholeheartedly”

  2. 1666 Main St, Sarasota FL 34236

    5 Superb 166 reviews

    “If you’re looking for jewelry or a custom piece, I HIGHLY recommend going here. Milan is extremely knowledgeable about his work, and my piece took a couple of months to complete. He ensured every detail was made carefully and to a high standard. He was great to work with!”

  3. 107 S Pineapple Ave, Sarasota FL 34236

    5 Superb 102 reviews

    “If you are looking for UNIQUE fine jewelry then this is the place for you. All real gold up to 24k! Well beyond the average jewelry you’ll find at any chain jewelry store. Check this place out before going to a chain store, I promise this super cute boutique will NOT disappoint!!”

  4. Advertisement

  5. 1459 Main Street, Sarasota FL 34236

    5 Superb 98 reviews

    “Amazing crystal store, first time visiting the shop. Staff was incredibly knowledgeable and equally enthusiastic. Great conversations. We’re avid collectors and their selection is extremely wide, from $5 agates to a $50,000 blue Bearpaw ammolite (which they could be selling for $150,000 for it’s size and color, truly a museum quality piece). Prices are very competitive, my galena was a third the price of comparable pieces in New York. They make their own jewelry, including the Ethiopian opal and spinel necklace you see below. Would highly recommended visiting to anyone interested in rocks and crystals. Excellent find.”

  6. 3210 Clark Rd, Sarasota FL 34231

    5 Superb 93 reviews

    “I had such a great experience here. Everyone was so nice and helpful. There was a wide variety of unique jewelry. This was my first pawn shop experience and I will definitely be back to purchase more jewelry.”

  7. 4039 Clark Rd, Sarasota FL 34233

    5 Superb 86 reviews

    “Excellent experience with LUXE. I had a watch repair done, and the workmanship was outstanding. The repair was completed quickly, the watch looks and runs perfectly, and communication was great throughout the process. Highly recommend LUXE for professional and reliable watch service.”

  8. 1542 4th St Unit 106, Sarasota FL 34236

    5 Superb 74 reviews

    “Thank you, Matt. Excellent customer service. I totally appreciate you working on my beloved bracelet that my Papa got me. I am so glad that I was able to interest it in your hands for this minor work so should anything come along in the future I have a goal to you and your team are amazing! Orion and Northern Star”

  9. 20 S Palm Ave, Sarasota FL 34236

    5 Superb 67 reviews

    “I recently have had the pleasure to work with Jeremy Thayer and his assistant, Jennie. I came in on the recommendation of my dear friends who loved his work. I wanted to re-set my Grandmother’s diamond ring and he was able to guide me with showing me a multitude of different design settings. I ended up finding a setting on Pinterest that I loved and he was able to take that image and create a custom ring that was perfect for me. His communication skills and honesty were so appreciated. He had such a nice way of calming my anxiety since he is an expert in this area and knows what will work and what will look proportionately, beautiful. It was a wonderful experience working with them. I am so grateful?”

  10. 5 N Boulevard of the Presidents, Sarasota FL 34236

    4.9 Superb 122 reviews

    “I can’t say enough about their exceptional customer service! I live in Japan and even though Patricia Locke is retired, they have corresponded with me to get my earrings designed by her repaired. Their staff have been very accommodating and responsive. Amazing!”

  11. 1301 Main St #101, Sarasota FL 34236

    5 Superb 64 reviews

    “I recently made 2 significant purchases from this jeweler. We were assisted by Sophia who was simply lovely! She listened to my interests and found the perfect ring for me! I had another ring modified with assistance from Sophia as well as another insightful and knowledgeable gentleman. I could not be happier with my rings-they truly exceeded my expectations. We meet several other staff members and each was remarkably helpful and kind. I recommend this business without reservation.”

  12. 368 St Armands Cir, Sarasota FL 34236

    4.9 Superb 109 reviews

    “Every summer vacation I visit this jewelry store and treat myself to something unique. The collections are beautiful and the staff is friendly and helpful. Great place to find something for yourself or pick up a unique piece for someone special!”

  13. 1861 Fruitville Road, Sarasota FL 34236

    4.9 Superb 84 reviews

    “The Artful Giraffe is truly one of Sarasota’s absolute gems and a staple in our community. This incredible space does so much more than showcase beautiful, one-of-a-kind local artwork, it provides an invaluable platform for talented local artists to share and sell their creations while giving the community the opportunity to discover and enjoy truly unique pieces. What makes The Artful Giraffe even more special is how deeply invested they are in fostering creativity through their extensive variety of classes and workshops. Whether you’re an experienced artist or simply looking to try something new, they create such a welcoming and inspiring environment for everyone. It’s places like The Artful Giraffe that keep Sarasota vibrant, connected, and full of character. Supporting local businesses and artists is so important, and this is one of the best places to do exactly that. A must-visit for locals and visitors alike!”

  14. 140 University Town Center Drive Suite Suite 234, Sarasota FL 34243

    4.8 Superb 174 reviews

    “We were so excited to finally purchase the Tag Heuer Gulf watch! The experience was incredible and will always remember the excitement of opening the box! Thank you for making this a special day for him!!”

  15. 28 S Boulevard of the Presidents unit B, Sarasota FL 34236

    5 Superb 37 reviews

    “We bought our lamp and rug from Max last year and fell in love with it. Not only was Max so incredibly kind and loving, but we make sure to stop by every year we are in town to say hello and see what treasures he has to offer. This year we bought 4 beautiful plates to hang in our kitchen! Can't wait to see the final look. Make sure to stop by when you are looking at all the shops in St. Armands Circle, by far the best in our opinion.”

  16. 821 Apricot Avenue, Sarasota FL 34237

    4.8 Superb 157 reviews

    “Enjoyed the bizarre at apricot and lime on Dolly Parton day. The food truck food is absolutely amazing. The chef does an incredible job, also, a lot of unique items in the bizarre.”

  17. 5921 McIntosh Road, Sarasota FL 34238

    5 Superb 35 reviews

    “Such a cool place with so many pieces. Unfortunately, I felt like the staff was deeply disinterested in my size 8 body and didn’t take me seriously at all. Maybe you only get helped if you pull up in a Mercedes. Or if you’re a regular customer. I was really excited to shop, but they didn’t even offer to go into the additional storage space (which they told me about three times) to get more of my shoes size when I mentioned that I had tried on every shoe available. I’m actually a fashion designer. They didn’t know that, but they sure did act like I was something sticky on the floor.”

  18. 1515 Ringling Blvd #990, Sarasota FL 34236

    4.9 Superb 54 reviews

    “My wife and I recently had the opportunity to do business with Kirk and it was a pleasure. Kirk was direct, very knowledgeable and very fair to deal with. I believe his 40+ years in the business have contributed to his wise demeanor as well as to his thoughtful and personable approach with the people he serves. I look forward to doing business with him again in the future.”

  19. 8491 S Tamiami Trl, Sarasota FL 34238

    4.9 Superb 53 reviews

    “After a recent bicycle accident, my hands swelled preventing ring removal. Rob carefully cut the custom ring off and miraculously duplicated a perfect custom new white gold ring. Rob and Carla helped pick out a matching white gold wedding ring. Their service, kindness and professionalism is ten stars. Highly recommend! J. Schwam Sarasota”

  20. 6635 Midnight Pass Road, Sarasota FL 34242

    4.9 Superb 54 reviews

    “You have got to check out this FUN little gift shop tucked in between some delicious restaurants. We will definitely be going back every time we're in the area. I only wish I could have bought a lot more than I did.”

  21. 1901 South Tamiami Trl D, Sarasota FL 34239

    4.8 Superb 110 reviews

    “Traveling through Sarasota for business trip and stopped at the cash for gold store in Sarasota and was greeted by Michael and Glenn who were very knowledgeable on the gold bars that I wanted to sell! I came in with three gold bars and was given a higher price at this location versus any other location. They gave me a great deal on the bars they bought from me! If your looking to sell or buy I would definitely stop at this location Sarasota Florida ( Cash for Gold store! ) If your smart, take your business to Michael and Glenn who will go beyond expectations to give you the best price in Florida! Definitely will be back for future business! If you go there you will leave with exceptional quality service! Way to Go Cash for Gold! You earned my business!”

  22. 1922 Bay Rd, Sarasota FL 34239

    4.8 Superb 102 reviews

    “Came in to get my Tissot PRX adjusted and the links corrected. Gary, the jeweler, and Mark, The sales professional, were amazing. Took care of me and even dealt with my OCD of making sure both sides of the bracelet were even I’ll continue to bring my watches back here for service and I’ll be buying jewelry and watches from them in the future”

  23. 2717 South Beneva Road, Sarasota FL 34232

    4.9 Superb 35 reviews

    “Donna's Beads is the best place to go for ALL of your beads needs! I had a family heirloom necklace, 80 years old, that needed to be restrung. I trusted Ashley with the task. I was not disappointed at all. She did an excellent job and used great care with her work. Do not hesitate to have Ashley do anything with your special beading needs.”

  24. 5105 Ocean Blvd, Sarasota FL 34242

    4.8 Superb 67 reviews

    “I’ve been visiting this location to have the rhodium plating redone on my wedding ring every few years when I’m vacationing in Siesta Key. Kris, the new owner, is great! He’s very pleasant to chat with and my ring looked incredible after he was finished with it. I would absolutely trust Kris with your jewelry needs. Will be back again for sure!”

  25. 6621 Gateway Ave #25, Sarasota FL 34231

    4.8 Superb 53 reviews

    “If you have any need for a jeweler, be sure to visit Koen Fine Jewelers! They are so knowledgeable and really take their time to give you personal service. I highly recommend them!”

  26. 3900 Clark Rd G2, Sarasota FL 34233

    4.8 Superb 47 reviews

    “I first visited Shepard Jewelry after seeing several strong recommendations on Nextdoor, and I am so glad I did. I brought in a very specific and somewhat delicate request: I needed a piece of jewelry modified to properly accommodate a hearing device. From the beginning, Nancy, Patrick, and Liza treated the project with genuine care, patience, and expertise. They welcomed multiple visits, walked me through different options, and took the time to make sure every component would function correctly while still preserving the beauty of the piece. Their attention to both the technical details and the aesthetics was truly impressive. The finished piece exceeded my expectations—not only did it work perfectly for my needs, but it was beautifully crafted and thoughtfully designed. It never felt rushed or transactional; instead, I felt listened to and supported throughout the entire process. Over the past year, I’ve also trusted Shepard Jewelry with appraisals and several repairs, and each experience has been just as impressive. Their workmanship is consistently excellent, their communication is clear and honest, and their customer service is unmatched. It’s rare to find a jeweler who combines such high-level craftsmanship with genuine kindness and professionalism. I wouldn’t go anywhere else.”

  27. 140 University Town Center Drive Spc 104, Sarasota FL 34243

    4.7 Superb 331 reviews

    “Had my watch fixed several times by different vendors and was always $800 plus and it broke quickly after the repair. Fast Fix did it for $450 and from what I can tell this repair will hold. Definitely recommend”

  28. 1451 Main St, Sarasota FL 34236

    4.8 Superb 37 reviews

    “This has become my new favorite go to place for something cute that doesn’t break the bank. Plus the shop keepers are so sweet and helpful! The only issue is when I get home and they post a new drop a few days later and I have to go back! 😏”

  29. 140 University Town Center Drive Suite 230, Sarasota FL 34243

    4.8 Superb 34 reviews

    “We had an awesome time in here for my daughter’s birthday. She was treated like royalty with all her friends. Sabrina helped us out and was remarkable.”

  30. 1446 Boulevard of the Arts, Sarasota FL 34236

    4.9 Superb 19 reviews

    “My wife found Harry's designs over 5 years ago and has wanted one of his designs as a setting for her mom's diamond. We finally had the opportunity to visit his gallery and she was able to find the perfect design that worked. Lilly was correct that seeing them in person is best because of Harry's unique designs. They were both very welcoming and easy to talk to.. Helping Wendy find the perfect wedding ring. My only complaint is now she wants at least 5 other pieces!”

  31. 6585 Gateway Avenue, Sarasota FL 34231

    5 Superb 13 reviews

    “I ❤️❤️❤️ this boutique. I stumbled upon in when driving home one day. The name is Maco Made in Colombia. It’s in Gulf Gate (Sarasota). The owner is a treasure. The store is bright and colorful. My eyes kept jumping from one beautiful thing to the next. There is handmade jewelry, handmade hats, dolls, purses, bowls, the list goes on. I absolutely recommend a visit to the store.As an extra bonus, they do events like Salsa dancing, wine and cheese, empanadas tasting, just to make a few. I will definitely go back for my holiday shopping!”

Advertisement

Jewelry Stores in nearby cities