Casablanca Inn On The Bay offers a mixed experience for guests, with its prime location in St. Augustine being a significant highlight. The hotel features a lively martini bar and provides a decent breakfast, both enjoyed by visitors. However, the accommodations vary in quality. Some guests noted cleanliness issues, such as dust under beds and mildew odors, while others mentioned that bathrooms need updates. Room maintenance is also a concern, with reports of peeling paint and non-functioning fireplaces.
While the reception staff is friendly and helpful, the lobby area is described as unimpressive. The parking situation can be complicated, requiring validation stickers for guests, and the parking area itself is a dirt road. Some rooms experience noise from the nearby bar and restaurant, which can disrupt peace, particularly in certain rooms that are less desirable.
Overall, while Casablanca Inn On The Bay has potential with its charming location and amenities, improvements in room maintenance, cleanliness, and noise control are necessary to enhance the guest experience. Many guests expressed a willingness to return if they could choose better rooms.
After a small miscommunication manger Victoria came to our rescue. What a great place to stay. Breakfast was good room was awesome and they are pet friendly. I would highly recommend this place to stay.
June 2026
Very nice and charming. Rooms were well kept. Price was reasonable. Will definitely stay again.
May 2026
The place is in the heart of Old Town and convenience and walkability is key. The rooms are basic and a bit dated...could use some renovation. The staff is Excellent. Everyone was so helpful and friendly!