Plato's Closet Batavia is a popular thrift store that offers a wide selection of stylish and affordable pre-owned clothing and accessories. The store is known for its friendly and helpful staff, with customers praising the owner's pleasant and fashionable demeanor. Shoppers can find a variety of brands, including Abercrombie and Hollister, often with new tags and at significantly discounted prices. The store's inventory caters to a range of styles, though some customers have noted a larger selection of crop tops and midriff-baring shirts during certain seasons. While the overall atmosphere and selection are generally positive, some customers have expressed frustration with the store's inconsistent policies regarding the acceptance of used items. Some have reported that items they purchased from the store were later rejected when they tried to resell them back. Despite these occasional issues, the majority of customers have had a positive experience at Plato's Closet Batavia. Many have praised the store's cleanliness, organization, and the kindness of the staff. Frequent shoppers have expressed their loyalty and enthusiasm, with one customer describing it as their "favorite Plato's" and vowing to return regularly.
I took my granddaughter there where she found 2 tops, therefore, she was happy.
May 2025
Didn't buy anything which is fine. I guess they have a hard time selling what my gf brought in but all bags were ripped open when they weren't dropped off that way. How am I supposed to carry it home?
March 2025
delaney who owns this store is SO KIND! my best friend and i went in and she was so nice. her store was FULL of amazing finds, so much abercrombie and hollister. my bestfriend found 4 pairs of abercrombie shorts NEW WITH TAGS for $8 a piece, how amazing. this is by far my favorite plato’s & we will absolutely be back.
