Casey's in Evansville, IN is a convenient one-stop-shop that offers a variety of services and products. Their pizza, made with fresh dough, real mozzarella, and quality toppings, is a standout, with customers praising the delicious specialty pizzas. The store also features appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and household essentials, making it a go-to for both quick meals and everyday needs. Customers appreciate the friendly and helpful staff, who provide great service whether it's morning, noon, or night. The prices are described as good, and the overall experience is fast and convenient. While there have been some minor issues, such as the lottery machine being down at times, the store is generally well-stocked and maintained, with a clean and organized layout. Despite sometimes being understaffed, especially at the food counter, customers continue to frequent this local gem, situated between Evansville and Newburgh. With its combination of quality food, essential items, and friendly service, Casey's in Evansville is a reliable and appreciated part of the community.
I'm thankful for your service. Very nice and friendly staff to take care of my every needs.
October 2024
Olivia checked us out, and the entire time she was texting on her phone while holding an unused cigarette in her hand. Before we walked in she was smoking outside, right in front of the entrance. So we had to walk thru her smoke coming into the gas station. She wasn’t rude but this was very unprofessional.
August 2024
Olivia is one hard worker! ALWAYS happy and ALWAYS very accommodating and friendly. Thanks so much
