Play It Again Sports Evansville is a store that buys and sells new and gently used sports equipment. It is described as an awesome, clean, and well-stocked store with very nice, knowledgeable, friendly, and helpful staff. Customers find great value, noting significant savings compared to retail sporting goods stores. The store issues store credit for unused items. It is a recommended alternative to big box stores for affordable gear, from softball helmets to cleats.
I have recommended this place so many times over the past couple months. Took a whole haul of my kids sports gear and they took almost all of it
April 2026
I love getting my disks for disk gulf here. They have a huge selection and decent prices. I mainly look for the 8$ ones but they have some on sale for less. Some do look like they are in rough shape but hey its a reuse sport shop and they sell new ones too. They also sell bags for a good price. All in all, its the place... read full comment
August 2025
I love the people who work there, and their dedication is great
