Barrington Jewels is the largest family-owned and operated jewelry store in Indianapolis, known for its quality pieces and personal touch. The store offers a wide selection of engagement, fashion, and loose stones, along with a large collection of Swiss and German watches. Customers can also benefit from in-house jewelry and watch repair services. Providing great customer service is a top priority, with staff members being friendly, kind, and professional. The owner, with a background in high-end jewelry, and his wife established the store in 1988, beginning in the Keystone Fashion Mall before moving to their standalone location. Over the years, the store has built a reputation for trustworthiness and caring service, with customers often returning for special pieces and repairs. Many customers appreciate the staff’s ability to understand their vision and provide excellent guidance, especially in custom jewelry work. They are praised for their creativity in repurposing legacy jewelry into new, meaningful pieces, such as transforming old bands into crosses or incorporating gems into unique designs. The store is also appreciated for its quick and attentive service, exemplified by a recent wedding anniversary visit where jewelry was cleaned and polished in just 30 minutes. Customers value the store’s ability to handle difficult jewelry needs, including resizing and customizing rings, even when other jewelers cannot. The selection is both beautiful and extensive, with the option to order additional pieces. Overall, Barrington Jewels is highly recommended for its trustworthy, caring service, and dedication to making each customer’s jewelry experience special.
Sophie was very helpful throughout the whole process. Will definitely choose Barrington and Sophie for all our jewelry needs!
July 2026
They’re reasonable and determined to help you with any jewelry issues they located a hard to find watch band that I couldn’t find and was able to install it as well I will be an returning customer
June 2026
Excellent and timely service and the staff is very friendly